{ "status": "failed", "author": { "provider": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.4-mini" }, "author_request_identity": { "provider": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.4-mini", "api_style": "responses", "reasoning_effort": "medium", "sampling": { "temperature": null } }, "reviewer": { "provider": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.5" }, "author_capability": { "schema_hash": "3935c6f40d3b8b9bb7c5672cdea37049a3cd9eb57c9f722b738397a45d77490c", "tool_count": 28, "supported": true, "failures": [], "usage": { "prompt_tokens": 133729, "completion_tokens": 3498 }, "mode": "openai_compatible_tool_calling", "probe_unavailable": false }, "reviewer_capability": { "schema_hash": "3935c6f40d3b8b9bb7c5672cdea37049a3cd9eb57c9f722b738397a45d77490c", "tool_count": 28, "supported": true, "failures": [], "usage": { "prompt_tokens": 133729, "completion_tokens": 1629 }, "mode": "openai_compatible_tool_calling", "probe_unavailable": false }, "structured_output_mode": { "author": "openai_compatible_tool_calling", "reviewer": "openai_compatible_tool_calling" }, "git_revision": "7533b298f1a23ed5d4c8a63982b2984258426b52", "protocol_version": "3.0", "runtime_profile_sha256": "bc2e2110a49929d96ad1e0d1996b2579ff1b56c80fd822423107bee7e560187e", "operation_contracts": [ { "atomic_id": "chamfer", "contract_hash": "eb5d3b87d055edf18fd8d7398cd104f5edf2bb9ae6994fc5eb870a3ab685d678", "contract_version": "3.0", "registry_revision": "1.3.1" }, { "atomic_id": "extrude_add_blind", "contract_hash": "fa9ffc9fd2141453fa18a389813dde2e2ef3fb4c7ef5d05e61d51d614309e95f", "contract_version": "3.0", "registry_revision": "1.3.1" }, { "atomic_id": "extrude_add_two_sided", "contract_hash": "35de3efa8ec4d4a1a37904f0c34084bb3fd2da07fa479a2b6d35e4837b210e9d", "contract_version": "3.0", "registry_revision": "1.3.1" }, { "atomic_id": "extrude_cut_blind", "contract_hash": "fe00ac225362469afe00cd4aee9b48259e8ceb74aa11d9a54ff038c6d12f0d50", "contract_version": "3.0", "registry_revision": "1.3.1" }, { "atomic_id": "fillet", "contract_hash": "db31dd9c749707cc9453fc248d7ca86ef4faaaf15376a40bd659c325b037c878", "contract_version": "3.0", "registry_revision": "1.3.1" }, { "atomic_id": "hole_blind", "contract_hash": "f62e12603feeca6d7e83acdab651fcb023e08a46c39fd1509e9dcb81d4f0c721", "contract_version": "3.0", "registry_revision": "1.3.1" }, { "atomic_id": "hole_counterbore", "contract_hash": "15a56094125780177ad75040d160430cc9f0a97928214bd0553acddfbff9aa16", "contract_version": "3.0", "registry_revision": "1.3.1" }, { "atomic_id": "hole_countersink", "contract_hash": "84b98d26d2a836105cf383bdfb1e733ea16bfa41935a08a48cf5c4d6c71ad49f", "contract_version": "3.0", "registry_revision": "1.3.1" }, { "atomic_id": "hole_wizard", "contract_hash": "35d56dd42ee933e0fe59f9cfc33391b25844bd270a8909703af7855ad6bd25f2", "contract_version": "3.0", "registry_revision": "1.3.1" }, { "atomic_id": "pattern_linear", "contract_hash": "ecf393713de82ac30ca326719774ed8315030d9d980d1370c95003505ce28471", "contract_version": "3.0", "registry_revision": "1.3.1" }, { "atomic_id": "pattern_mirror", "contract_hash": "ec014e6c1639d98e2a50a26c88256ad0a9ad0fd8a027cd57b710c07d8bf3ecb8", "contract_version": "3.0", "registry_revision": "1.3.1" }, { "atomic_id": "reference_axis", "contract_hash": "2ebeda16a1fc50aefb0fa923794f43e609aca07dbd5059968824dfcf97532aaa", "contract_version": "3.0", "registry_revision": "1.3.1" }, { "atomic_id": "reference_plane", "contract_hash": "86968365856f972fdacef1a739be379458a563be5763c97d4f18e6b93d14ef55", "contract_version": "3.0", "registry_revision": "1.3.1" }, { "atomic_id": "revolve_add", "contract_hash": "8c0c5e842fb868cad4dc37f5d195d0d8971878bc5c23a7eb9017d829ea36c6db", "contract_version": "3.0", "registry_revision": "1.3.1" }, { "atomic_id": "revolve_cut", "contract_hash": "101c9d285c46cf8c6d3bba516cde2bf9002eee0e9cc62d66cade676c3a71db56", "contract_version": "3.0", "registry_revision": "1.3.1" }, { "atomic_id": "sphere_add", "contract_hash": "ef855cadd1f295b16ebbf11538557efaf790ff0c44262c9ae61e769242844c95", "contract_version": "3.0", "registry_revision": "1.3.1" } ], "verifier_registry_version": "cad.verifier-registry.v1", "verifier_schema_hash": "7a05abe600903feabb57bc8c77e26042c28ca13fe5d5caeb94f37351ce8adf97", "token_comparison": { "schema_version": "cad.token-comparison.v1", "status": "not_required" }, "baseline_report": "", "results": [ { "scenario": "three_hole_linkage", "repetition": 1, "success": false, "outcome": "failed", "started_at": "2026-08-31T21:02:28.490535+00:00", "finished_at": "2026-08-31T21:06:47.492311+00:00", "duration_ms": 259002, "terminal": { "taskId": "cad_4bfab705790e", "lifecycle": "failed", "code": "FAILED_AUTHOR_FORMAT", "message": "Author repeatedly failed the same canonical schema or state contract.", "tool": "submit_cdsl_fragment", "field_errors": [ { "path": "/feature/selector_tokens/0", "message": "'root' is not one of []" } ] }, "projection": { "schema_version": "3.0", "task_id": "cad_4bfab705790e", "phase": "FAILED", "lifecycle": "failed", "state_version": 23, "active_revision": "", "current_revision": "", "published_revision": "", "pending_action": null, "active_candidate_id": "", "repair_required": true, "last_error": "FAILED_AUTHOR_FORMAT", "retry_from_phase": "", "requirements_draft_path": "documents/requirements-draft-v3-61764f015449-cad_4bfab705790e_inv_650eedbe95a.json", "requirements_review_path": "documents/requirements-review-95c3c7c2c161-cad_4bfab705790e_inv_7f3c98543a0.json", "requirements_contract_path": "documents/requirements-contract-b9ac54942f43-cad_4bfab705790e_inv_7f3c98543a0.json", "action_ledger_summary": [ { "sequence": 12, "at": "2026-08-31 21:04:09", "action_id": "act_010", "candidate_id": "candidate_ceace4909e1449f0", "claim_results": [ { "claim_id": "claim_001", "claim_kind": "solid_count_equals", "deterministic": true, "evidence": { "solid_count": 1 }, "status": "pass" }, { "claim_id": "claim_002", "claim_kind": "bbox_rank_dimension_mm", "deterministic": true, "evidence": { "actual_mm": 10.0, "rank": "minimum", "tolerance_mm": 0.1 }, "status": "pass" }, { "claim_id": "claim_003", "claim_kind": "through_cylindrical_bore", "deterministic": true, "evidence": { "reason": "the target bore has not been introduced at this checkpoint" }, "status": "pending" }, { "claim_id": "claim_004", "claim_kind": "collinear_through_bore_chain", "deterministic": true, "evidence": { "actual_count": 0, "diameter_mm": 12, "expected_count": 3 }, "status": "fail" }, { "claim_id": "claim_005", "claim_kind": "outer_cylindrical_surface", "deterministic": true, "evidence": { "reason": "the target external cylindrical surface has not been introduced at this checkpoint" }, "status": "pending" }, { "claim_id": "claim_006", "claim_kind": "visual", "deterministic": false, "evidence": { "reason": "requires independent visual review" }, "status": "pending" } ], "event": "candidate_rejected", "reason": "deterministic_claim_failed", "stage_id": "stage_ceace4909e1449f0e6bc", "working_head": "cad_4bfab705790e:root:v9" }, { "sequence": 13, "at": "2026-08-31 21:04:16", "corrective_intent": "Introduce the three 12 mm collinear through bores so the candidate satisfies the required bore chain before any further outer-profile work.", "decision": "return_to_action_selection", "event": "geometry_conclusion", "evidence_refs": [ "evidence_current_state", "evidence_ledger_12" ], "root_cause": "The current solid has no introduced 12 mm through-bore chain, so the deterministic claim for three collinear holes fails with actual_count 0.", "working_head": "cad_4bfab705790e:root:v13", "working_head_before": "cad_4bfab705790e:root:v12" }, { "sequence": 14, "at": "2026-08-31 21:04:21", "action_id": "act_014", "atomic_id": "revolve_add", "contract_hash": "8c0c5e842fb868cad4dc37f5d195d0d8971878bc5c23a7eb9017d829ea36c6db", "event": "proposed", "expected_change": "Record a geometry conclusion from the current evidence, then establish the outer link envelope around the three collinear hole centers so the 32 mm outer regions can be formed continuously.", "intent": "Progress from the failed bore-chain checkpoint by selecting a constructive action that can support the required three-hole connecting link geometry.", "requirement_ids": [ "req_001" ], "working_head": "cad_4bfab705790e:root:v13" }, { "sequence": 15, "at": "2026-08-31 21:04:40", "action_id": "act_014", "candidate_id": "candidate_5d2c8afa51ad22d5", "event": "candidate_building", "fragment_hash": "0073faaf5f0099a5e0e6e2c0e645952232d8045b0b7bc9150722c9f758f96a6e", "stage_id": "stage_5d2c8afa51ad22d521d5" }, { "sequence": 16, "at": "2026-08-31 21:04:41", "action_id": "act_014", "candidate_id": "candidate_5d2c8afa51ad22d5", "claim_results": [ { "claim_id": "claim_001", "claim_kind": "solid_count_equals", "deterministic": true, "evidence": { "solid_count": 1 }, "status": "pass" }, { "claim_id": "claim_002", "claim_kind": "bbox_rank_dimension_mm", "deterministic": true, "evidence": { "actual_mm": 32.0, "expected_mm": 10, "rank": "minimum", "tolerance_mm": 0.1 }, "status": "fail" }, { "claim_id": "claim_003", "claim_kind": "through_cylindrical_bore", "deterministic": true, "evidence": { "reason": "the target bore has not been introduced at this checkpoint" }, "status": "pending" }, { "claim_id": "claim_004", "claim_kind": "collinear_through_bore_chain", "deterministic": true, "evidence": { "actual_count": 0, "diameter_mm": 12, "expected_count": 3 }, "status": "fail" }, { "claim_id": "claim_005", "claim_kind": "outer_cylindrical_surface", "deterministic": true, "evidence": { "reason": "the target external cylindrical-surface pattern is incomplete at this checkpoint" }, "status": "pending" }, { "claim_id": "claim_006", "claim_kind": "visual", "deterministic": false, "evidence": { "reason": "requires independent visual review" }, "status": "pending" } ], "event": "candidate_rejected", "reason": "deterministic_claim_failed", "stage_id": "stage_5d2c8afa51ad22d521d5", "working_head": "cad_4bfab705790e:root:v13" }, { "sequence": 17, "at": "2026-08-31 21:04:51", "corrective_intent": "Reduce the minimum bounding dimension to 10 mm and add the three 12 mm collinear through bores required by the link.", "decision": "return_to_action_selection", "event": "geometry_conclusion", "evidence_refs": [ "evidence_current_state", "evidence_ledger_12", "evidence_ledger_16" ], "root_cause": "The candidate still presents a 32 mm minimum bounding dimension instead of the required 10 mm thickness, and the required chain of three 12 mm collinear through bores is absent.", "working_head": "cad_4bfab705790e:root:v17", "working_head_before": "cad_4bfab705790e:root:v16" }, { "sequence": 18, "at": "2026-08-31 21:05:02", "action_id": "act_018", "atomic_id": "extrude_add_blind", "contract_hash": "fa9ffc9fd2141453fa18a389813dde2e2ef3fb4c7ef5d05e61d51d614309e95f", "event": "proposed", "expected_change": "Add a 10 mm-thick link body that spans the three collinear hole stations while keeping the outer profile smooth around the three 32 mm circular regions.", "intent": "Replace the failed envelope with a correctly thin base solid that can then accept the three 12 mm through bores at 60 mm and 80 mm spacing.", "requirement_ids": [ "req_001" ], "working_head": "cad_4bfab705790e:root:v17" }, { "sequence": 19, "at": "2026-08-31 21:05:37", "action_id": "act_018", "candidate_id": "candidate_0cf669338f89dcea", "event": "candidate_building", "fragment_hash": "95daa987f1433ef22cd833a7b1cf9d8df18c5f7cfc1231c8144b2ac9ce571a06", "stage_id": "stage_0cf669338f89dcea3803" }, { "sequence": 20, "at": "2026-08-31 21:05:38", "action_id": "act_018", "candidate_id": "candidate_0cf669338f89dcea", "claim_results": [ { "claim_id": "claim_001", "claim_kind": "solid_count_equals", "deterministic": true, "evidence": { "solid_count": 1 }, "status": "pass" }, { "claim_id": "claim_002", "claim_kind": "bbox_rank_dimension_mm", "deterministic": true, "evidence": { "actual_mm": 10.0, "rank": "minimum", "tolerance_mm": 0.1 }, "status": "pass" }, { "claim_id": "claim_003", "claim_kind": "through_cylindrical_bore", "deterministic": true, "evidence": { "reason": "the target bore has not been introduced at this checkpoint" }, "status": "pending" }, { "claim_id": "claim_004", "claim_kind": "collinear_through_bore_chain", "deterministic": true, "evidence": { "actual_count": 0, "diameter_mm": 12, "expected_count": 3 }, "status": "fail" }, { "claim_id": "claim_005", "claim_kind": "outer_cylindrical_surface", "deterministic": true, "evidence": { "reason": "the target external cylindrical surface has not been introduced at this checkpoint" }, "status": "pending" }, { "claim_id": "claim_006", "claim_kind": "visual", "deterministic": false, "evidence": { "reason": "requires independent visual review" }, "status": "pending" } ], "event": "candidate_rejected", "reason": "deterministic_claim_failed", "stage_id": "stage_0cf669338f89dcea3803", "working_head": "cad_4bfab705790e:root:v17" }, { "sequence": 21, "at": "2026-08-31 21:05:46", "corrective_intent": "Introduce the three 12 mm through bores at the specified 60 mm and 80 mm center spacing while preserving the 10 mm-thick link body and smooth outer profile.", "decision": "return_to_action_selection", "event": "geometry_conclusion", "evidence_refs": [ "evidence_current_state", "evidence_ledger_20", "evidence_ledger_16" ], "root_cause": "The candidate still lacks the required chain of three 12 mm collinear through bores; the deterministic check reports expected_count 3 and actual_count 0.", "working_head": "cad_4bfab705790e:root:v21", "working_head_before": "cad_4bfab705790e:root:v20" }, { "sequence": 22, "at": "2026-08-31 21:05:56", "action_id": "act_022", "atomic_id": "hole_wizard", "contract_hash": "35d56dd42ee933e0fe59f9cfc33391b25844bd270a8909703af7855ad6bd25f2", "event": "proposed", "expected_change": "Add three 12 mm through holes on one straight centerline with adjacent center-to-center spacing of 60 mm and 80 mm, preserving the 10 mm-thick link body and its smooth outer profile around the three 32 mm outer circular regions.", "intent": "Repair the missing bore chain so the link satisfies the three-hole geometry and spacing requirements.", "requirement_ids": [ "req_001" ], "working_head": "cad_4bfab705790e:root:v21" }, { "sequence": 23, "at": "2026-08-31 21:06:47", "event": "failed_author_format", "field_errors": [ { "message": "'root' is not one of []", "path": "/feature/selector_tokens/0" } ], "tool": "submit_cdsl_fragment" } ], "revisions": [] }, "usage": { "calls": 27, "prompt_tokens": 172617, "completion_tokens": 11330, "context_chars": 149841, "records": [ { "cache_hit": false, "completion_tokens": 753, "context_chars": 738, "model_id": "gpt-5.4-mini", "prompt_tokens": 6103, "provider_id": "openai", "raw_arguments_hash": "b31e35ced1304bbb11c4838def7ff4500590c3e1e99b19e895865819ac014511", "retry_reason": "", "tool": "submit_requirements_draft_batch", "total_tokens": 6856, "usage_available": true }, { "cache_hit": false, "completion_tokens": 18, "context_chars": 1798, "model_id": "gpt-5.4-mini", "prompt_tokens": 4924, "provider_id": "openai", "raw_arguments_hash": "44136fa355b3678a1146ad16f7e8649e94fb4fc21fe77e8310c060f61caaff8a", "retry_reason": "", "tool": "finalize_requirements_draft", "total_tokens": 4942, "usage_available": true }, { "cache_hit": false, "completion_tokens": 130, "context_chars": 2702, "model_id": "gpt-5.5", "prompt_tokens": 5317, "provider_id": "openai", "raw_arguments_hash": "c7131599418d32d312d55ae5ea02e19f6e3f996b4727ba24b502ae703ffde79b", "retry_reason": "", "role": "reviewer", "tool": "review_requirements", "total_tokens": 5447, "usage_available": true }, { "cache_hit": false, "completion_tokens": 540, "context_chars": 2879, "model_id": "gpt-5.4-mini", "prompt_tokens": 6768, "provider_id": "openai", "raw_arguments_hash": "bc13ce2f9484835c5f7259723c062519ba9a7a663cc897a9db4e5e9d02079ebb", "retry_reason": "", "tool": "patch_requirements_draft", "total_tokens": 7308, "usage_available": true }, { "cache_hit": false, "completion_tokens": 80, "context_chars": 1921, "model_id": "gpt-5.4-mini", "prompt_tokens": 4963, "provider_id": "openai", "raw_arguments_hash": "44136fa355b3678a1146ad16f7e8649e94fb4fc21fe77e8310c060f61caaff8a", "retry_reason": "", "tool": "finalize_requirements_draft", "total_tokens": 5043, "usage_available": true }, { "cache_hit": false, "completion_tokens": 71, "context_chars": 2813, "model_id": "gpt-5.5", "prompt_tokens": 5356, "provider_id": "openai", "raw_arguments_hash": "00996cae282886750e3169d668db3145d5aad3fa73c825b1b9d5d423613bdb52", "retry_reason": "", "role": "reviewer", "tool": "review_requirements", "total_tokens": 5427, "usage_available": true }, { "cache_hit": false, "completion_tokens": 535, "context_chars": 3275, "model_id": "gpt-5.4-mini", "prompt_tokens": 6906, "provider_id": "openai", "raw_arguments_hash": "8ffdc546a8f69ebcbece01c43065f1c9ba58704773bca18c8eba8e8f3ea0999f", "retry_reason": "", "tool": "patch_requirements_draft", "total_tokens": 7441, "usage_available": true }, { "cache_hit": false, "completion_tokens": 83, "context_chars": 2063, "model_id": "gpt-5.4-mini", "prompt_tokens": 5008, "provider_id": "openai", "raw_arguments_hash": "44136fa355b3678a1146ad16f7e8649e94fb4fc21fe77e8310c060f61caaff8a", "retry_reason": "", "tool": "finalize_requirements_draft", "total_tokens": 5091, "usage_available": true }, { "cache_hit": false, "completion_tokens": 71, "context_chars": 2941, "model_id": "gpt-5.5", "prompt_tokens": 5401, "provider_id": "openai", "raw_arguments_hash": "00996cae282886750e3169d668db3145d5aad3fa73c825b1b9d5d423613bdb52", "retry_reason": "", "role": "reviewer", "tool": "review_requirements", "total_tokens": 5472, "usage_available": true }, { "cache_hit": false, "completion_tokens": 574, "context_chars": 3518, "model_id": "gpt-5.4-mini", "prompt_tokens": 5626, "provider_id": "openai", "raw_arguments_hash": "51e4c49dbe54ef49e71a9a44fb546f20fc0c135830fcb7ea76830fd7e9eee144", "retry_reason": "", "tool": "propose_next_action", "total_tokens": 6200, "usage_available": true }, { "cache_hit": false, "completion_tokens": 42, "context_chars": 3985, "model_id": "gpt-5.4-mini", "prompt_tokens": 5588, "provider_id": "openai", "raw_arguments_hash": "8792f2d3dc4c687bb8f502cac0cacf8c60bef8fac8fa6235e4687a33e6e4fd75", "retry_reason": "", "tool": "get_cdsl_operation_contract", "total_tokens": 5630, "usage_available": true }, { "cache_hit": false, "completion_tokens": 651, "context_chars": 8966, "model_id": "gpt-5.4-mini", "prompt_tokens": 7301, "provider_id": "openai", "raw_arguments_hash": "42aec572c7689d24779f1a498d27d6d30615e0462820ec31d3972d0dcab0332f", "retry_reason": "", "tool": "submit_cdsl_fragment", "total_tokens": 7952, "usage_available": true }, { "cache_hit": false, "completion_tokens": 301, "context_chars": 6087, "model_id": "gpt-5.4-mini", "prompt_tokens": 6464, "provider_id": "openai", "raw_arguments_hash": "ad06f696f825bc76ec5beae83f2d0c36049bb363b8e4b919be531f671858908d", "retry_reason": "", "tool": "record_geometry_conclusion", "total_tokens": 6765, "usage_available": true }, { "cache_hit": false, "completion_tokens": 110, "context_chars": 5148, "model_id": "gpt-5.4-mini", "prompt_tokens": 6219, "provider_id": "openai", "raw_arguments_hash": "714858e585787d8283e7f2ca4a43c2dd2342ee0661bc62e9d475adc262043023", "retry_reason": "", "tool": "propose_next_action", "total_tokens": 6329, "usage_available": true }, { "cache_hit": false, "completion_tokens": 291, "context_chars": 5858, "model_id": "gpt-5.4-mini", "prompt_tokens": 6224, "provider_id": "openai", "raw_arguments_hash": "3eb5ffb0825869c6d02cb5475ef7a3eed6043fb3427e246f7cadae36116f344f", "retry_reason": "", "tool": "get_cdsl_operation_contract", "total_tokens": 6515, "usage_available": true }, { "cache_hit": false, "completion_tokens": 631, "context_chars": 11552, "model_id": "gpt-5.4-mini", "prompt_tokens": 8185, "provider_id": "openai", "raw_arguments_hash": "f7e84c1b32337c677d467a7c2c742c6ded4fed9324d31b55fc37a3a0df7b0ea2", "retry_reason": "", "tool": "submit_cdsl_fragment", "total_tokens": 8816, "usage_available": true }, { "cache_hit": false, "completion_tokens": 482, "context_chars": 6715, "model_id": "gpt-5.4-mini", "prompt_tokens": 6570, "provider_id": "openai", "raw_arguments_hash": "a90fb6f6cb1bace0d7e018750410d017c76e7632f34ba57d58003e07b095041d", "retry_reason": "", "tool": "record_geometry_conclusion", "total_tokens": 7052, "usage_available": true }, { "cache_hit": false, "completion_tokens": 637, "context_chars": 5328, "model_id": "gpt-5.4-mini", "prompt_tokens": 6275, "provider_id": "openai", "raw_arguments_hash": "c6eb3866e3884ac9f06c7e71ba29ad314e9c4dd5550855bc2f1950f7f976b6c5", "retry_reason": "", "tool": "propose_next_action", "total_tokens": 6912, "usage_available": true }, { "cache_hit": false, "completion_tokens": 258, "context_chars": 5859, "model_id": "gpt-5.4-mini", "prompt_tokens": 6284, "provider_id": "openai", "raw_arguments_hash": "974e4909e81a1042ff09a6b0643ffc31564486ff77edd853617dddd29ce788e3", "retry_reason": "", "tool": "get_cdsl_operation_contract", "total_tokens": 6542, "usage_available": true }, { "cache_hit": false, "completion_tokens": 1780, "context_chars": 10840, "model_id": "gpt-5.4-mini", "prompt_tokens": 7997, "provider_id": "openai", "raw_arguments_hash": "056770517833658fa72bc0e1861ed7f0de751a4032f779ebde8c819f3d3f4c6c", "retry_reason": "", "tool": "submit_cdsl_fragment", "total_tokens": 9777, "usage_available": true }, { "cache_hit": false, "completion_tokens": 378, "context_chars": 6451, "model_id": "gpt-5.4-mini", "prompt_tokens": 6526, "provider_id": "openai", "raw_arguments_hash": "e2b6b67fcc6b745be979924e38eab922c1335da811c2e9d14abefb5fbe74480a", "retry_reason": "", "tool": "record_geometry_conclusion", "total_tokens": 6904, "usage_available": true }, { "cache_hit": false, "completion_tokens": 525, "context_chars": 5309, "model_id": "gpt-5.4-mini", "prompt_tokens": 6273, "provider_id": "openai", "raw_arguments_hash": "52d1ef989302ea6123acd02649eeae532f376da48bde3642593350f6016b3d50", "retry_reason": "", "tool": "propose_next_action", "total_tokens": 6798, "usage_available": true }, { "cache_hit": false, "completion_tokens": 339, "context_chars": 5889, "model_id": "gpt-5.4-mini", "prompt_tokens": 6262, "provider_id": "openai", "raw_arguments_hash": "3467e359229c7accc64be605b3c082f429a4ef0597c789225972c9087a900320", "retry_reason": "", "tool": "get_cdsl_operation_contract", "total_tokens": 6601, "usage_available": true }, { "cache_hit": false, "completion_tokens": 319, "context_chars": 12274, "model_id": "gpt-5.4-mini", "prompt_tokens": 7940, "provider_id": "openai", "raw_arguments_hash": "7158eb578f1a9e7dfb9c82cbb3db1d3a9614a78c0503d02e8f977a96dd451911", "retry_reason": "", "tool": "inspect_topology", "total_tokens": 8259, "usage_available": true }, { "cache_hit": false, "completion_tokens": 460, "context_chars": 12352, "model_id": "gpt-5.4-mini", "prompt_tokens": 8426, "provider_id": "openai", "raw_arguments_hash": "b7d9ae25ca6416c848c8f2345de31e6ffcee4d6f3fb0b0fb6b592ee5d78c0982", "retry_reason": "", "tool": "submit_cdsl_fragment", "total_tokens": 8886, "usage_available": true }, { "cache_hit": false, "completion_tokens": 636, "context_chars": 6288, "model_id": "gpt-5.4-mini", "prompt_tokens": 6855, "provider_id": "openai", "raw_arguments_hash": "c3e222ef4310fa1ab0a4ab8744e94974a11c9fcd0e2d781f1186dc5790883d66", "retry_reason": "", "tool": "submit_cdsl_fragment", "total_tokens": 7491, "usage_available": true }, { "cache_hit": false, "completion_tokens": 635, "context_chars": 6292, "model_id": "gpt-5.4-mini", "prompt_tokens": 6856, "provider_id": "openai", "raw_arguments_hash": "15140c7cf9135d6822f50207cdaab857389a85eaff524ec8a5ff1b02129fe21c", "retry_reason": "", "tool": "submit_cdsl_fragment", "total_tokens": 7491, "usage_available": true } ] }, "checks": { "expected_terminal_phase": false, "token_budget": true, "call_budget": true, "author_turn_budget": true, "reviewer_turn_budget": true, "required_claims": true, "acceptance_contract_coverage": false, "required_operations": false, "required_operation_alternative": false, "immutable_artifacts": false, "required_artifact_evidence": false, "artifact_manifest": true, "action_ledger": true, "unique_revisions": true, "deterministic_claims_pass": false, "raw_argument_audit": false, "no_schema_or_decision_rejections": false }, "acceptance_coverage": { "required_claim_kinds": [ "bbox_rank_dimension_mm", "collinear_through_bore_chain", "solid_count_equals", "through_cylindrical_bore", "visual" ], "covered_claim_kinds": [ "bbox_rank_dimension_mm", "collinear_through_bore_chain", "solid_count_equals", "through_cylindrical_bore", "visual" ], "required_claims": [ { "claim_kind": "solid_count_equals", "expected": { "value": 1 } }, { "claim_kind": "bbox_rank_dimension_mm", "expected": { "rank": "minimum", "value": 10 } }, { "claim_kind": "through_cylindrical_bore", "expected": { "diameter_mm": 12, "count": 3 } }, { "claim_kind": "collinear_through_bore_chain", "expected": { "diameter_mm": 12, "adjacent_distances_mm": [ 60, 80 ], "tolerance_mm": 0.1 } }, { "claim_kind": "visual", "expected": {} } ], "missing_claims": [], "validation_capability_gaps": [ { "id": "linkage_outer_circles", "description": "32 mm outer circles with smoothly connected segments" } ], "complete": false }, "failure_attribution": { "layer": "model_format_or_decision", "reason_code": "FAILED_AUTHOR_FORMAT", "evidence_codes": [ "CLAIM_VERIFICATION_FAILED", "AUTHOR_FORMAT_INVALID", "FAILED_AUTHOR_FORMAT" ], "failed_checks": [ "expected_terminal_phase", "acceptance_contract_coverage", "required_operations", "required_operation_alternative", "immutable_artifacts", "required_artifact_evidence", "deterministic_claims_pass", "raw_argument_audit", "no_schema_or_decision_rejections" ] }, "rejection_codes": [ "AUTHOR_FORMAT_INVALID", "AUTHOR_FORMAT_INVALID", "AUTHOR_FORMAT_INVALID" ], "schema_rejection_count": 3, "retry_count": 6, "rollback_count": 0, "candidate_ids": [ "candidate_0cf669338f89dcea", "candidate_5d2c8afa51ad22d5", "candidate_ceace4909e1449f0" ], "revision_ids": [], "final_claim_results": [], "redacted_correlation_ids": [ "84d1bb9d2ae8f6429374", "d4c52917fa0b982d84bc", "000e3f8a730430599986", "25aedf3ea8db34fe7482", "879b36da0aa61d04fcd0", "6f7f74dcdf695f10083e", "cc1f6e59186e9788e958", "3febc88dc3f0bc971a24", "cf55291858aca64d12eb", "1ac5325fcabb48513393", "7162b3e5ea731d2159c2", "3bc8ca0bcf61c1c86304", "6b145c554c69b7b9e049", "1ac4ac32423643941511", "c5673a9d351e6baf0a66", "360a07a543882ae79b52", "b0a0764b186f187983d2", "fc4e162bea59a316d5c8", "5958d4dcf41788dc3b2f" ], "tool_audits": [ { "audit_id": 1, "at": "2026-08-31 21:02:41", "actor": "author", "tool": "submit_requirements_draft_batch", "raw_arguments_hash": "b31e35ced1304bbb11c4838def7ff4500590c3e1e99b19e895865819ac014511", "canonical_schema_valid": true, "field_errors": [], "state_binding": { "active_revision": "", "binding_valid": true, "contract_hash": "", "contract_hash_current": true, "expected_working_head": "cad_4bfab705790e:root:v0", "phase": "DRAFTING_REQUIREMENTS", "selector_snapshot_id": "", "supplied_working_head": "", "working_head": "cad_4bfab705790e:root:v0", "working_head_binding_source": "current_state", "working_head_matches": true }, "returned_tool": "submit_requirements_draft_batch", "single_allowed_call": true }, { "audit_id": 2, "at": "2026-08-31 21:02:47", "actor": "author", "tool": "finalize_requirements_draft", "raw_arguments_hash": "44136fa355b3678a1146ad16f7e8649e94fb4fc21fe77e8310c060f61caaff8a", "canonical_schema_valid": true, "field_errors": [], "state_binding": { "active_revision": "", "binding_valid": true, "contract_hash": "", "contract_hash_current": true, "expected_working_head": "cad_4bfab705790e:root:v1", "phase": "DRAFTING_REQUIREMENTS", "selector_snapshot_id": "", "supplied_working_head": "", "working_head": "cad_4bfab705790e:root:v1", "working_head_binding_source": "current_state", "working_head_matches": true }, "returned_tool": "finalize_requirements_draft", "single_allowed_call": true }, { "audit_id": 3, "at": "2026-08-31 21:02:53", "actor": "reviewer", "tool": "review_requirements", "raw_arguments_hash": "c7131599418d32d312d55ae5ea02e19f6e3f996b4727ba24b502ae703ffde79b", "canonical_schema_valid": true, "field_errors": [], "state_binding": { "active_revision": "", "binding_valid": true, "contract_hash": "", "contract_hash_current": true, "expected_working_head": "cad_4bfab705790e:root:v2", "phase": "REVIEWING_REQUIREMENTS", "selector_snapshot_id": "", "supplied_working_head": "", "working_head": "cad_4bfab705790e:root:v2", "working_head_binding_source": "current_state", "working_head_matches": true }, "returned_tool": "review_requirements", "single_allowed_call": true }, { "audit_id": 4, "at": "2026-08-31 21:03:05", "actor": "author", "tool": "patch_requirements_draft", "raw_arguments_hash": "bc13ce2f9484835c5f7259723c062519ba9a7a663cc897a9db4e5e9d02079ebb", "canonical_schema_valid": true, "field_errors": [], "state_binding": { "active_revision": "", "binding_valid": true, "contract_hash": "", "contract_hash_current": true, "expected_working_head": "cad_4bfab705790e:root:v3", "phase": "DRAFTING_REQUIREMENTS", "selector_snapshot_id": "", "supplied_working_head": "", "working_head": "cad_4bfab705790e:root:v3", "working_head_binding_source": "current_state", "working_head_matches": true }, "returned_tool": "patch_requirements_draft", "single_allowed_call": true }, { "audit_id": 5, "at": "2026-08-31 21:03:08", "actor": "author", "tool": "finalize_requirements_draft", "raw_arguments_hash": "44136fa355b3678a1146ad16f7e8649e94fb4fc21fe77e8310c060f61caaff8a", "canonical_schema_valid": true, "field_errors": [], "state_binding": { "active_revision": "", "binding_valid": true, "contract_hash": "", "contract_hash_current": true, "expected_working_head": "cad_4bfab705790e:root:v4", "phase": "DRAFTING_REQUIREMENTS", "selector_snapshot_id": "", "supplied_working_head": "", "working_head": "cad_4bfab705790e:root:v4", "working_head_binding_source": "current_state", "working_head_matches": true }, "returned_tool": "finalize_requirements_draft", "single_allowed_call": true }, { "audit_id": 6, "at": "2026-08-31 21:03:15", "actor": "reviewer", "tool": "review_requirements", "raw_arguments_hash": "00996cae282886750e3169d668db3145d5aad3fa73c825b1b9d5d423613bdb52", "canonical_schema_valid": true, "field_errors": [], "state_binding": { "active_revision": "", "binding_valid": true, "contract_hash": "", "contract_hash_current": true, "expected_working_head": "cad_4bfab705790e:root:v5", "phase": "REVIEWING_REQUIREMENTS", "selector_snapshot_id": "", "supplied_working_head": "", "working_head": "cad_4bfab705790e:root:v5", "working_head_binding_source": "current_state", "working_head_matches": true }, "returned_tool": "review_requirements", "single_allowed_call": true }, { "audit_id": 7, "at": "2026-08-31 21:03:25", "actor": "author", "tool": "patch_requirements_draft", "raw_arguments_hash": "8ffdc546a8f69ebcbece01c43065f1c9ba58704773bca18c8eba8e8f3ea0999f", "canonical_schema_valid": true, "field_errors": [], "state_binding": { "active_revision": "", "binding_valid": true, "contract_hash": "", "contract_hash_current": true, "expected_working_head": "cad_4bfab705790e:root:v6", "phase": "DRAFTING_REQUIREMENTS", "selector_snapshot_id": "", "supplied_working_head": "", "working_head": "cad_4bfab705790e:root:v6", "working_head_binding_source": "current_state", "working_head_matches": true }, "returned_tool": "patch_requirements_draft", "single_allowed_call": true }, { "audit_id": 8, "at": "2026-08-31 21:03:29", "actor": "author", "tool": "finalize_requirements_draft", "raw_arguments_hash": "44136fa355b3678a1146ad16f7e8649e94fb4fc21fe77e8310c060f61caaff8a", "canonical_schema_valid": true, "field_errors": [], "state_binding": { "active_revision": "", "binding_valid": true, "contract_hash": "", "contract_hash_current": true, "expected_working_head": "cad_4bfab705790e:root:v7", "phase": "DRAFTING_REQUIREMENTS", "selector_snapshot_id": "", "supplied_working_head": "", "working_head": "cad_4bfab705790e:root:v7", "working_head_binding_source": "current_state", "working_head_matches": true }, "returned_tool": "finalize_requirements_draft", "single_allowed_call": true }, { "audit_id": 9, "at": "2026-08-31 21:03:34", "actor": "reviewer", "tool": "review_requirements", "raw_arguments_hash": "00996cae282886750e3169d668db3145d5aad3fa73c825b1b9d5d423613bdb52", "canonical_schema_valid": true, "field_errors": [], "state_binding": { "active_revision": "", "binding_valid": true, "contract_hash": "", "contract_hash_current": true, "expected_working_head": "cad_4bfab705790e:root:v8", "phase": "REVIEWING_REQUIREMENTS", "selector_snapshot_id": "", "supplied_working_head": "", "working_head": "cad_4bfab705790e:root:v8", "working_head_binding_source": "current_state", "working_head_matches": true }, "returned_tool": "review_requirements", "single_allowed_call": true }, { "audit_id": 10, "at": "2026-08-31 21:03:51", "actor": "author", "tool": "propose_next_action", "raw_arguments_hash": "51e4c49dbe54ef49e71a9a44fb546f20fc0c135830fcb7ea76830fd7e9eee144", "canonical_schema_valid": true, "field_errors": [], "state_binding": { "active_revision": "", "binding_valid": true, "contract_hash": "", "contract_hash_current": true, "expected_working_head": "cad_4bfab705790e:root:v9", "phase": "AWAITING_ACTION", "selector_snapshot_id": "", "supplied_working_head": "cad_4bfab705790e:root:v9", "working_head": "cad_4bfab705790e:root:v9", "working_head_binding_source": "schema_const", "working_head_matches": true }, "returned_tool": "propose_next_action", "single_allowed_call": true }, { "audit_id": 11, "at": "2026-08-31 21:03:55", "actor": "author", "tool": "get_cdsl_operation_contract", "raw_arguments_hash": "8792f2d3dc4c687bb8f502cac0cacf8c60bef8fac8fa6235e4687a33e6e4fd75", "canonical_schema_valid": true, "field_errors": [], "state_binding": { "active_revision": "", "binding_valid": true, "contract_hash": "fa9ffc9fd2141453fa18a389813dde2e2ef3fb4c7ef5d05e61d51d614309e95f", "contract_hash_current": true, "expected_working_head": "cad_4bfab705790e:root:v10", "phase": "ACTION_PENDING", "selector_snapshot_id": "", "supplied_working_head": "cad_4bfab705790e:root:v10", "working_head": "cad_4bfab705790e:root:v10", "working_head_binding_source": "schema_const", "working_head_matches": true }, "returned_tool": "get_cdsl_operation_contract", "single_allowed_call": true }, { "audit_id": 12, "at": "2026-08-31 21:04:08", "actor": "author", "tool": "submit_cdsl_fragment", "raw_arguments_hash": "42aec572c7689d24779f1a498d27d6d30615e0462820ec31d3972d0dcab0332f", "canonical_schema_valid": true, "field_errors": [], "state_binding": { "active_revision": "", "binding_valid": true, "contract_hash": "fa9ffc9fd2141453fa18a389813dde2e2ef3fb4c7ef5d05e61d51d614309e95f", "contract_hash_current": true, "expected_working_head": "cad_4bfab705790e:root:v10", "phase": "ACTION_PENDING", "selector_snapshot_id": "", "supplied_working_head": "", "working_head": "cad_4bfab705790e:root:v10", "working_head_binding_source": "current_state", "working_head_matches": true }, "returned_tool": "submit_cdsl_fragment", "single_allowed_call": true }, { "audit_id": 13, "at": "2026-08-31 21:04:16", "actor": "author", "tool": "record_geometry_conclusion", "raw_arguments_hash": "ad06f696f825bc76ec5beae83f2d0c36049bb363b8e4b919be531f671858908d", "canonical_schema_valid": true, "field_errors": [], "state_binding": { "active_revision": "", "binding_valid": true, "contract_hash": "fa9ffc9fd2141453fa18a389813dde2e2ef3fb4c7ef5d05e61d51d614309e95f", "contract_hash_current": true, "expected_working_head": "cad_4bfab705790e:root:v12", "phase": "ACTION_PENDING", "selector_snapshot_id": "", "supplied_working_head": "cad_4bfab705790e:root:v12", "working_head": "cad_4bfab705790e:root:v12", "working_head_binding_source": "schema_const", "working_head_matches": true }, "returned_tool": "record_geometry_conclusion", "single_allowed_call": true }, { "audit_id": 14, "at": "2026-08-31 21:04:21", "actor": "author", "tool": "propose_next_action", "raw_arguments_hash": "714858e585787d8283e7f2ca4a43c2dd2342ee0661bc62e9d475adc262043023", "canonical_schema_valid": true, "field_errors": [], "state_binding": { "active_revision": "", "binding_valid": true, "contract_hash": "", "contract_hash_current": true, "expected_working_head": "cad_4bfab705790e:root:v13", "phase": "AWAITING_ACTION", "selector_snapshot_id": "", "supplied_working_head": "cad_4bfab705790e:root:v13", "working_head": "cad_4bfab705790e:root:v13", "working_head_binding_source": "schema_const", "working_head_matches": true }, "returned_tool": "propose_next_action", "single_allowed_call": true }, { "audit_id": 15, "at": "2026-08-31 21:04:28", "actor": "author", "tool": "get_cdsl_operation_contract", "raw_arguments_hash": "3eb5ffb0825869c6d02cb5475ef7a3eed6043fb3427e246f7cadae36116f344f", "canonical_schema_valid": true, "field_errors": [], "state_binding": { "active_revision": "", "binding_valid": true, "contract_hash": "8c0c5e842fb868cad4dc37f5d195d0d8971878bc5c23a7eb9017d829ea36c6db", "contract_hash_current": true, "expected_working_head": "cad_4bfab705790e:root:v14", "phase": "ACTION_PENDING", "selector_snapshot_id": "", "supplied_working_head": "cad_4bfab705790e:root:v14", "working_head": "cad_4bfab705790e:root:v14", "working_head_binding_source": "schema_const", "working_head_matches": true }, "returned_tool": "get_cdsl_operation_contract", "single_allowed_call": true }, { "audit_id": 16, "at": "2026-08-31 21:04:40", "actor": "author", "tool": "submit_cdsl_fragment", "raw_arguments_hash": "f7e84c1b32337c677d467a7c2c742c6ded4fed9324d31b55fc37a3a0df7b0ea2", "canonical_schema_valid": true, "field_errors": [], "state_binding": { "active_revision": "", "binding_valid": true, "contract_hash": "8c0c5e842fb868cad4dc37f5d195d0d8971878bc5c23a7eb9017d829ea36c6db", "contract_hash_current": true, "expected_working_head": "cad_4bfab705790e:root:v14", "phase": "ACTION_PENDING", "selector_snapshot_id": "", "supplied_working_head": "", "working_head": "cad_4bfab705790e:root:v14", "working_head_binding_source": "current_state", "working_head_matches": true }, "returned_tool": "submit_cdsl_fragment", "single_allowed_call": true }, { "audit_id": 17, "at": "2026-08-31 21:04:51", "actor": "author", "tool": "record_geometry_conclusion", "raw_arguments_hash": "a90fb6f6cb1bace0d7e018750410d017c76e7632f34ba57d58003e07b095041d", "canonical_schema_valid": true, "field_errors": [], "state_binding": { "active_revision": "", "binding_valid": true, "contract_hash": "8c0c5e842fb868cad4dc37f5d195d0d8971878bc5c23a7eb9017d829ea36c6db", "contract_hash_current": true, "expected_working_head": "cad_4bfab705790e:root:v16", "phase": "ACTION_PENDING", "selector_snapshot_id": "", "supplied_working_head": "cad_4bfab705790e:root:v16", "working_head": "cad_4bfab705790e:root:v16", "working_head_binding_source": "schema_const", "working_head_matches": true }, "returned_tool": "record_geometry_conclusion", "single_allowed_call": true }, { "audit_id": 18, "at": "2026-08-31 21:05:02", "actor": "author", "tool": "propose_next_action", "raw_arguments_hash": "c6eb3866e3884ac9f06c7e71ba29ad314e9c4dd5550855bc2f1950f7f976b6c5", "canonical_schema_valid": true, "field_errors": [], "state_binding": { "active_revision": "", "binding_valid": true, "contract_hash": "", "contract_hash_current": true, "expected_working_head": "cad_4bfab705790e:root:v17", "phase": "AWAITING_ACTION", "selector_snapshot_id": "", "supplied_working_head": "cad_4bfab705790e:root:v17", "working_head": "cad_4bfab705790e:root:v17", "working_head_binding_source": "schema_const", "working_head_matches": true }, "returned_tool": "propose_next_action", "single_allowed_call": true }, { "audit_id": 19, "at": "2026-08-31 21:05:09", "actor": "author", "tool": "get_cdsl_operation_contract", "raw_arguments_hash": "974e4909e81a1042ff09a6b0643ffc31564486ff77edd853617dddd29ce788e3", "canonical_schema_valid": true, "field_errors": [], "state_binding": { "active_revision": "", "binding_valid": true, "contract_hash": "fa9ffc9fd2141453fa18a389813dde2e2ef3fb4c7ef5d05e61d51d614309e95f", "contract_hash_current": true, "expected_working_head": "cad_4bfab705790e:root:v18", "phase": "ACTION_PENDING", "selector_snapshot_id": "", "supplied_working_head": "cad_4bfab705790e:root:v18", "working_head": "cad_4bfab705790e:root:v18", "working_head_binding_source": "schema_const", "working_head_matches": true }, "returned_tool": "get_cdsl_operation_contract", "single_allowed_call": true }, { "audit_id": 20, "at": "2026-08-31 21:05:37", "actor": "author", "tool": "submit_cdsl_fragment", "raw_arguments_hash": "056770517833658fa72bc0e1861ed7f0de751a4032f779ebde8c819f3d3f4c6c", "canonical_schema_valid": true, "field_errors": [], "state_binding": { "active_revision": "", "binding_valid": true, "contract_hash": "fa9ffc9fd2141453fa18a389813dde2e2ef3fb4c7ef5d05e61d51d614309e95f", "contract_hash_current": true, "expected_working_head": "cad_4bfab705790e:root:v18", "phase": "ACTION_PENDING", "selector_snapshot_id": "", "supplied_working_head": "", "working_head": "cad_4bfab705790e:root:v18", "working_head_binding_source": "current_state", "working_head_matches": true }, "returned_tool": "submit_cdsl_fragment", "single_allowed_call": true }, { "audit_id": 21, "at": "2026-08-31 21:05:46", "actor": "author", "tool": "record_geometry_conclusion", "raw_arguments_hash": "e2b6b67fcc6b745be979924e38eab922c1335da811c2e9d14abefb5fbe74480a", "canonical_schema_valid": true, "field_errors": [], "state_binding": { "active_revision": "", "binding_valid": true, "contract_hash": "fa9ffc9fd2141453fa18a389813dde2e2ef3fb4c7ef5d05e61d51d614309e95f", "contract_hash_current": true, "expected_working_head": "cad_4bfab705790e:root:v20", "phase": "ACTION_PENDING", "selector_snapshot_id": "", "supplied_working_head": "cad_4bfab705790e:root:v20", "working_head": "cad_4bfab705790e:root:v20", "working_head_binding_source": "schema_const", "working_head_matches": true }, "returned_tool": "record_geometry_conclusion", "single_allowed_call": true }, { "audit_id": 22, "at": "2026-08-31 21:05:56", "actor": "author", "tool": "propose_next_action", "raw_arguments_hash": "52d1ef989302ea6123acd02649eeae532f376da48bde3642593350f6016b3d50", "canonical_schema_valid": true, "field_errors": [], "state_binding": { "active_revision": "", "binding_valid": true, "contract_hash": "", "contract_hash_current": true, "expected_working_head": "cad_4bfab705790e:root:v21", "phase": "AWAITING_ACTION", "selector_snapshot_id": "", "supplied_working_head": "cad_4bfab705790e:root:v21", "working_head": "cad_4bfab705790e:root:v21", "working_head_binding_source": "schema_const", "working_head_matches": true }, "returned_tool": "propose_next_action", "single_allowed_call": true }, { "audit_id": 23, "at": "2026-08-31 21:06:04", "actor": "author", "tool": "get_cdsl_operation_contract", "raw_arguments_hash": "3467e359229c7accc64be605b3c082f429a4ef0597c789225972c9087a900320", "canonical_schema_valid": true, "field_errors": [], "state_binding": { "active_revision": "", "binding_valid": true, "contract_hash": "35d56dd42ee933e0fe59f9cfc33391b25844bd270a8909703af7855ad6bd25f2", "contract_hash_current": true, "expected_working_head": "cad_4bfab705790e:root:v22", "phase": "ACTION_PENDING", "selector_snapshot_id": "", "supplied_working_head": "cad_4bfab705790e:root:v22", "working_head": "cad_4bfab705790e:root:v22", "working_head_binding_source": "schema_const", "working_head_matches": true }, "returned_tool": "get_cdsl_operation_contract", "single_allowed_call": true }, { "audit_id": 24, "at": "2026-08-31 21:06:14", "actor": "author", "tool": "inspect_topology", "raw_arguments_hash": "7158eb578f1a9e7dfb9c82cbb3db1d3a9614a78c0503d02e8f977a96dd451911", "canonical_schema_valid": true, "field_errors": [], "state_binding": { "active_revision": "", "binding_valid": true, "contract_hash": "35d56dd42ee933e0fe59f9cfc33391b25844bd270a8909703af7855ad6bd25f2", "contract_hash_current": true, "expected_working_head": "cad_4bfab705790e:root:v22", "phase": "ACTION_PENDING", "selector_snapshot_id": "", "supplied_working_head": "cad_4bfab705790e:root:v22", "working_head": "cad_4bfab705790e:root:v22", "working_head_binding_source": "schema_const", "working_head_matches": true }, "returned_tool": "inspect_topology", "single_allowed_call": true }, { "audit_id": 25, "at": "2026-08-31 21:06:24", "actor": "author", "tool": "submit_cdsl_fragment", "raw_arguments_hash": "b7d9ae25ca6416c848c8f2345de31e6ffcee4d6f3fb0b0fb6b592ee5d78c0982", "canonical_schema_valid": false, "field_errors": [ { "message": "'' is not one of []", "path": "/feature/selector_tokens/0" } ], "state_binding": { "active_revision": "", "binding_valid": false, "contract_hash": "35d56dd42ee933e0fe59f9cfc33391b25844bd270a8909703af7855ad6bd25f2", "contract_hash_current": true, "expected_working_head": "cad_4bfab705790e:root:v22", "phase": "ACTION_PENDING", "selector_snapshot_id": "", "supplied_working_head": "", "working_head": "cad_4bfab705790e:root:v22", "working_head_binding_source": "current_state", "working_head_matches": true }, "returned_tool": "submit_cdsl_fragment", "single_allowed_call": true }, { "audit_id": 26, "at": "2026-08-31 21:06:36", "actor": "author", "tool": "submit_cdsl_fragment", "raw_arguments_hash": "c3e222ef4310fa1ab0a4ab8744e94974a11c9fcd0e2d781f1186dc5790883d66", "canonical_schema_valid": false, "field_errors": [ { "message": "'root' is not one of []", "path": "/feature/selector_tokens/0" } ], "state_binding": { "active_revision": "", "binding_valid": false, "contract_hash": "35d56dd42ee933e0fe59f9cfc33391b25844bd270a8909703af7855ad6bd25f2", "contract_hash_current": true, "expected_working_head": "cad_4bfab705790e:root:v22", "phase": "ACTION_PENDING", "selector_snapshot_id": "", "supplied_working_head": "", "working_head": "cad_4bfab705790e:root:v22", "working_head_binding_source": "current_state", "working_head_matches": true }, "returned_tool": "submit_cdsl_fragment", "single_allowed_call": true }, { "audit_id": 27, "at": "2026-08-31 21:06:47", "actor": "author", "tool": "submit_cdsl_fragment", "raw_arguments_hash": "15140c7cf9135d6822f50207cdaab857389a85eaff524ec8a5ff1b02129fe21c", "canonical_schema_valid": false, "field_errors": [ { "message": "'root' is not one of []", "path": "/feature/selector_tokens/0" } ], "state_binding": { "active_revision": "", "binding_valid": false, "contract_hash": "35d56dd42ee933e0fe59f9cfc33391b25844bd270a8909703af7855ad6bd25f2", "contract_hash_current": true, "expected_working_head": "cad_4bfab705790e:root:v22", "phase": "ACTION_PENDING", "selector_snapshot_id": "", "supplied_working_head": "", "working_head": "cad_4bfab705790e:root:v22", "working_head_binding_source": "current_state", "working_head_matches": true }, "returned_tool": "submit_cdsl_fragment", "single_allowed_call": true } ], "artifact_root": "/Users/lk/Projects/cdsl-cad/backend/live-evals/20260831T205806Z/artifacts/cad_4bfab705790e", "action_ledger_path": "/Users/lk/Projects/cdsl-cad/backend/live-evals/20260831T205806Z/artifacts/cad_4bfab705790e/actions/action-ledger.jsonl", "artifact_manifest": { "schema_version": "cad.live-eval-artifact-manifest.v1", "artifact_root": "/Users/lk/Projects/cdsl-cad/backend/live-evals/20260831T205806Z/artifacts/cad_4bfab705790e", "files": [ { "path": "actions/action-ledger.jsonl", "sha256": "8c3f4cf1b01e8fe08a1b41782fa091d82482343c1af71319b9873b60696ce55d" }, { "path": "completion.md", "sha256": "4e8ad3920e3c92606ba28f950770f1a923529553dbb2246213c1facce9961269" }, { "path": "documents/requirements-contract-b9ac54942f43-cad_4bfab705790e_inv_7f3c98543a0.json", "sha256": "22ed34c240c99e567bfa760be3c7a31bc5e5872493f22b6494829413597e8737" }, { "path": "documents/requirements-draft-v1-7a8956b293c5-cad_4bfab705790e_inv_96a2e27f713.json", "sha256": "0d392606dc8acbff52cf58e7dee3c131cc7439a696f68b5ec02d87981d536a03" }, { "path": "documents/requirements-draft-v2-7a3b57e1a317-cad_4bfab705790e_inv_701e5e31390.json", "sha256": "7cd7172cae1abf8fce8668d9747e953562ae3532e529a4a6cf92aa292c1b0d7d" }, { "path": "documents/requirements-draft-v3-61764f015449-cad_4bfab705790e_inv_650eedbe95a.json", "sha256": "afc470b83d98b6a607599442acb086ea0d21ebbbf6819a654faa3493027bcc8a" }, { "path": "documents/requirements-review-95c3c7c2c161-cad_4bfab705790e_inv_7f3c98543a0.json", "sha256": "674ff2208e459c4f4a86fa8e9edd0d6dbb98ffcad37ad7a2bff96bc7d0ec5423" }, { "path": "documents/requirements-review-95c3c7c2c161-cad_4bfab705790e_inv_c13114aaefe.json", "sha256": "674ff2208e459c4f4a86fa8e9edd0d6dbb98ffcad37ad7a2bff96bc7d0ec5423" }, { "path": "documents/requirements-review-cc333790e85d-cad_4bfab705790e_inv_3a5e691e574.json", "sha256": "c973d42f566b181dfe792fea59ef775ae9bfa6e198cc1c8cc88cc5260b29742a" }, { "path": "requirements-contract.json", "sha256": "22ed34c240c99e567bfa760be3c7a31bc5e5872493f22b6494829413597e8737" }, { "path": "requirements-index.json", "sha256": "d3082a1e5cd79fdc2ee51958333774412f45d58ec9055565aac087de25cde2b8" }, { "path": "requirements.md", "sha256": "ef588dda0e4dce2709b453caf489b477e23b4b3edf694a9b7a706816f6aa39d9" } ] }, "ledger": [ { "sequence": 1, "at": "2026-08-31 21:02:41", "draft_path": "documents/requirements-draft-v1-7a8956b293c5-cad_4bfab705790e_inv_96a2e27f713.json", "draft_revision": 1, "event": "requirements_draft_updated", "invocation_id": "cad_4bfab705790e_inv_96a2e27f71342f4e", "item_count": 1 }, { "sequence": 2, "at": "2026-08-31 21:02:47", "draft_revision": 1, "event": "requirements_review_requested", "invocation_id": "cad_4bfab705790e_inv_48c0f1b12a0ee759" }, { "sequence": 3, "at": "2026-08-31 21:02:53", "event": "requirements_review_revise", "invocation_id": "cad_4bfab705790e_inv_3a5e691e5746423d", "review_path": "documents/requirements-review-cc333790e85d-cad_4bfab705790e_inv_3a5e691e574.json" }, { "sequence": 4, "at": "2026-08-31 21:03:05", "draft_path": "documents/requirements-draft-v2-7a3b57e1a317-cad_4bfab705790e_inv_701e5e31390.json", "draft_revision": 2, "event": "requirements_draft_patched", "invocation_id": "cad_4bfab705790e_inv_701e5e3139044f78", "item_count": 1 }, { "sequence": 5, "at": "2026-08-31 21:03:08", "draft_revision": 2, "event": "requirements_review_requested", "invocation_id": "cad_4bfab705790e_inv_c7cf71863867c7dd" }, { "sequence": 6, "at": "2026-08-31 21:03:15", "event": "requirements_evaluation_oracle_revise", "invocation_id": "cad_4bfab705790e_inv_c13114aaefe0f216", "missing_claims": [ { "claim_kind": "solid_count_equals", "expected": { "value": 1 } }, { "claim_kind": "bbox_rank_dimension_mm", "expected": { "rank": "minimum", "value": 10 } }, { "claim_kind": "through_cylindrical_bore", "expected": { "count": 3, "diameter_mm": 12 } } ], "oracle_path": "documents/evaluation-contract-oracle-4369fa31d9b6.json", "review_path": "documents/requirements-review-95c3c7c2c161-cad_4bfab705790e_inv_c13114aaefe.json" }, { "sequence": 7, "at": "2026-08-31 21:03:25", "draft_path": "documents/requirements-draft-v3-61764f015449-cad_4bfab705790e_inv_650eedbe95a.json", "draft_revision": 3, "event": "requirements_draft_patched", "invocation_id": "cad_4bfab705790e_inv_650eedbe95afb3d7", "item_count": 1 }, { "sequence": 8, "at": "2026-08-31 21:03:29", "draft_revision": 3, "event": "requirements_review_requested", "invocation_id": "cad_4bfab705790e_inv_a5f9a976e1c24ab3" }, { "sequence": 9, "at": "2026-08-31 21:03:34", "contract_hash": "73778b28c0f6fa21a9beab2a327b7bdb1fd87297e7439e9aa33dedd607af4336", "contract_path": "documents/requirements-contract-b9ac54942f43-cad_4bfab705790e_inv_7f3c98543a0.json", "event": "requirements_contract_frozen", "invocation_id": "cad_4bfab705790e_inv_7f3c98543a0a62cb", "requirement_count": 1, "review_path": "documents/requirements-review-95c3c7c2c161-cad_4bfab705790e_inv_7f3c98543a0.json" }, { "sequence": 10, "at": "2026-08-31 21:03:51", "action_id": "act_010", "atomic_id": "extrude_add_blind", "contract_hash": "fa9ffc9fd2141453fa18a389813dde2e2ef3fb4c7ef5d05e61d51d614309e95f", "event": "proposed", "expected_change": "Create a 10 mm thick solid link body as the base mass for the three-hole part.", "intent": "Establish the required minimum thickness and single-solid foundation before cutting the three 12 mm through holes and shaping the outer continuous profile.", "requirement_ids": [ "req_001" ], "working_head": "cad_4bfab705790e:root:v9" }, { "sequence": 11, "at": "2026-08-31 21:04:09", "action_id": "act_010", "candidate_id": "candidate_ceace4909e1449f0", "event": "candidate_building", "fragment_hash": "f1f3c0fcf12b358dc5f66f3a5166af486b26a0dfa789e4a672e554dfa1dfa585", "stage_id": "stage_ceace4909e1449f0e6bc" }, { "sequence": 12, "at": "2026-08-31 21:04:09", "action_id": "act_010", "candidate_id": "candidate_ceace4909e1449f0", "claim_results": [ { "claim_id": "claim_001", "claim_kind": "solid_count_equals", "deterministic": true, "evidence": { "solid_count": 1 }, "status": "pass" }, { "claim_id": "claim_002", "claim_kind": "bbox_rank_dimension_mm", "deterministic": true, "evidence": { "actual_mm": 10.0, "rank": "minimum", "tolerance_mm": 0.1 }, "status": "pass" }, { "claim_id": "claim_003", "claim_kind": "through_cylindrical_bore", "deterministic": true, "evidence": { "reason": "the target bore has not been introduced at this checkpoint" }, "status": "pending" }, { "claim_id": "claim_004", "claim_kind": "collinear_through_bore_chain", "deterministic": true, "evidence": { "actual_count": 0, "diameter_mm": 12, "expected_count": 3 }, "status": "fail" }, { "claim_id": "claim_005", "claim_kind": "outer_cylindrical_surface", "deterministic": true, "evidence": { "reason": "the target external cylindrical surface has not been introduced at this checkpoint" }, "status": "pending" }, { "claim_id": "claim_006", "claim_kind": "visual", "deterministic": false, "evidence": { "reason": "requires independent visual review" }, "status": "pending" } ], "event": "candidate_rejected", "reason": "deterministic_claim_failed", "stage_id": "stage_ceace4909e1449f0e6bc", "working_head": "cad_4bfab705790e:root:v9" }, { "sequence": 13, "at": "2026-08-31 21:04:16", "corrective_intent": "Introduce the three 12 mm collinear through bores so the candidate satisfies the required bore chain before any further outer-profile work.", "decision": "return_to_action_selection", "event": "geometry_conclusion", "evidence_refs": [ "evidence_current_state", "evidence_ledger_12" ], "root_cause": "The current solid has no introduced 12 mm through-bore chain, so the deterministic claim for three collinear holes fails with actual_count 0.", "working_head": "cad_4bfab705790e:root:v13", "working_head_before": "cad_4bfab705790e:root:v12" }, { "sequence": 14, "at": "2026-08-31 21:04:21", "action_id": "act_014", "atomic_id": "revolve_add", "contract_hash": "8c0c5e842fb868cad4dc37f5d195d0d8971878bc5c23a7eb9017d829ea36c6db", "event": "proposed", "expected_change": "Record a geometry conclusion from the current evidence, then establish the outer link envelope around the three collinear hole centers so the 32 mm outer regions can be formed continuously.", "intent": "Progress from the failed bore-chain checkpoint by selecting a constructive action that can support the required three-hole connecting link geometry.", "requirement_ids": [ "req_001" ], "working_head": "cad_4bfab705790e:root:v13" }, { "sequence": 15, "at": "2026-08-31 21:04:40", "action_id": "act_014", "candidate_id": "candidate_5d2c8afa51ad22d5", "event": "candidate_building", "fragment_hash": "0073faaf5f0099a5e0e6e2c0e645952232d8045b0b7bc9150722c9f758f96a6e", "stage_id": "stage_5d2c8afa51ad22d521d5" }, { "sequence": 16, "at": "2026-08-31 21:04:41", "action_id": "act_014", "candidate_id": "candidate_5d2c8afa51ad22d5", "claim_results": [ { "claim_id": "claim_001", "claim_kind": "solid_count_equals", "deterministic": true, "evidence": { "solid_count": 1 }, "status": "pass" }, { "claim_id": "claim_002", "claim_kind": "bbox_rank_dimension_mm", "deterministic": true, "evidence": { "actual_mm": 32.0, "expected_mm": 10, "rank": "minimum", "tolerance_mm": 0.1 }, "status": "fail" }, { "claim_id": "claim_003", "claim_kind": "through_cylindrical_bore", "deterministic": true, "evidence": { "reason": "the target bore has not been introduced at this checkpoint" }, "status": "pending" }, { "claim_id": "claim_004", "claim_kind": "collinear_through_bore_chain", "deterministic": true, "evidence": { "actual_count": 0, "diameter_mm": 12, "expected_count": 3 }, "status": "fail" }, { "claim_id": "claim_005", "claim_kind": "outer_cylindrical_surface", "deterministic": true, "evidence": { "reason": "the target external cylindrical-surface pattern is incomplete at this checkpoint" }, "status": "pending" }, { "claim_id": "claim_006", "claim_kind": "visual", "deterministic": false, "evidence": { "reason": "requires independent visual review" }, "status": "pending" } ], "event": "candidate_rejected", "reason": "deterministic_claim_failed", "stage_id": "stage_5d2c8afa51ad22d521d5", "working_head": "cad_4bfab705790e:root:v13" }, { "sequence": 17, "at": "2026-08-31 21:04:51", "corrective_intent": "Reduce the minimum bounding dimension to 10 mm and add the three 12 mm collinear through bores required by the link.", "decision": "return_to_action_selection", "event": "geometry_conclusion", "evidence_refs": [ "evidence_current_state", "evidence_ledger_12", "evidence_ledger_16" ], "root_cause": "The candidate still presents a 32 mm minimum bounding dimension instead of the required 10 mm thickness, and the required chain of three 12 mm collinear through bores is absent.", "working_head": "cad_4bfab705790e:root:v17", "working_head_before": "cad_4bfab705790e:root:v16" }, { "sequence": 18, "at": "2026-08-31 21:05:02", "action_id": "act_018", "atomic_id": "extrude_add_blind", "contract_hash": "fa9ffc9fd2141453fa18a389813dde2e2ef3fb4c7ef5d05e61d51d614309e95f", "event": "proposed", "expected_change": "Add a 10 mm-thick link body that spans the three collinear hole stations while keeping the outer profile smooth around the three 32 mm circular regions.", "intent": "Replace the failed envelope with a correctly thin base solid that can then accept the three 12 mm through bores at 60 mm and 80 mm spacing.", "requirement_ids": [ "req_001" ], "working_head": "cad_4bfab705790e:root:v17" }, { "sequence": 19, "at": "2026-08-31 21:05:37", "action_id": "act_018", "candidate_id": "candidate_0cf669338f89dcea", "event": "candidate_building", "fragment_hash": "95daa987f1433ef22cd833a7b1cf9d8df18c5f7cfc1231c8144b2ac9ce571a06", "stage_id": "stage_0cf669338f89dcea3803" }, { "sequence": 20, "at": "2026-08-31 21:05:38", "action_id": "act_018", "candidate_id": "candidate_0cf669338f89dcea", "claim_results": [ { "claim_id": "claim_001", "claim_kind": "solid_count_equals", "deterministic": true, "evidence": { "solid_count": 1 }, "status": "pass" }, { "claim_id": "claim_002", "claim_kind": "bbox_rank_dimension_mm", "deterministic": true, "evidence": { "actual_mm": 10.0, "rank": "minimum", "tolerance_mm": 0.1 }, "status": "pass" }, { "claim_id": "claim_003", "claim_kind": "through_cylindrical_bore", "deterministic": true, "evidence": { "reason": "the target bore has not been introduced at this checkpoint" }, "status": "pending" }, { "claim_id": "claim_004", "claim_kind": "collinear_through_bore_chain", "deterministic": true, "evidence": { "actual_count": 0, "diameter_mm": 12, "expected_count": 3 }, "status": "fail" }, { "claim_id": "claim_005", "claim_kind": "outer_cylindrical_surface", "deterministic": true, "evidence": { "reason": "the target external cylindrical surface has not been introduced at this checkpoint" }, "status": "pending" }, { "claim_id": "claim_006", "claim_kind": "visual", "deterministic": false, "evidence": { "reason": "requires independent visual review" }, "status": "pending" } ], "event": "candidate_rejected", "reason": "deterministic_claim_failed", "stage_id": "stage_0cf669338f89dcea3803", "working_head": "cad_4bfab705790e:root:v17" }, { "sequence": 21, "at": "2026-08-31 21:05:46", "corrective_intent": "Introduce the three 12 mm through bores at the specified 60 mm and 80 mm center spacing while preserving the 10 mm-thick link body and smooth outer profile.", "decision": "return_to_action_selection", "event": "geometry_conclusion", "evidence_refs": [ "evidence_current_state", "evidence_ledger_20", "evidence_ledger_16" ], "root_cause": "The candidate still lacks the required chain of three 12 mm collinear through bores; the deterministic check reports expected_count 3 and actual_count 0.", "working_head": "cad_4bfab705790e:root:v21", "working_head_before": "cad_4bfab705790e:root:v20" }, { "sequence": 22, "at": "2026-08-31 21:05:56", "action_id": "act_022", "atomic_id": "hole_wizard", "contract_hash": "35d56dd42ee933e0fe59f9cfc33391b25844bd270a8909703af7855ad6bd25f2", "event": "proposed", "expected_change": "Add three 12 mm through holes on one straight centerline with adjacent center-to-center spacing of 60 mm and 80 mm, preserving the 10 mm-thick link body and its smooth outer profile around the three 32 mm outer circular regions.", "intent": "Repair the missing bore chain so the link satisfies the three-hole geometry and spacing requirements.", "requirement_ids": [ "req_001" ], "working_head": "cad_4bfab705790e:root:v21" }, { "sequence": 23, "at": "2026-08-31 21:06:47", "event": "failed_author_format", "field_errors": [ { "message": "'root' is not one of []", "path": "/feature/selector_tokens/0" } ], "tool": "submit_cdsl_fragment" } ], "invocations": [ { "invocation_id": "cad_4bfab705790e_inv_96a2e27f71342f4e", "idempotency_key": "528c45cb95f9b99159a206b1e0718169802d1cebef5b85f55ee9675ad2994f7e", "status": "finished", "result": { "result_type": "accepted", "payload": { "draft_revision": 1, "draft_ids": [ "draft_001" ] } }, "created_at": "2026-08-31 21:02:41", "updated_at": "2026-08-31 21:02:41" }, { "invocation_id": "cad_4bfab705790e_inv_48c0f1b12a0ee759", "idempotency_key": "9d0fdc44c08178deaceed3fe5202d584025a25936e461a6b124ab2ffc1437e2e", "status": "finished", "result": { "result_type": "accepted", "payload": { "phase": "REVIEWING_REQUIREMENTS", "draft_revision": 1 } }, "created_at": "2026-08-31 21:02:47", "updated_at": "2026-08-31 21:02:47" }, { "invocation_id": "cad_4bfab705790e_inv_3a5e691e5746423d", "idempotency_key": "7eb4f84d8c94fcd0ef29165609ada10df931260c08b7369eea661dcbfede1583", "status": "finished", "result": { "result_type": "accepted", "payload": { "phase": "DRAFTING_REQUIREMENTS", "review": { "verdict": "revise", "coverage": [ { "source_id": "src_001", "requirement_ids": [ "req_001" ] } ], "item_verdicts": [ { "draft_id": "draft_001", "verdict": "revise", "reason_code": "missing_dimension", "question": null } ], "issues": [ "Missing executable acceptance for the 32 mm outer diameter around each hole. The current visual claim represents smooth connected outer lobes under the stated validation gap, but the 32 mm diameter is an independently measurable source dimension and is only present in visual/prose, not an executable claim." ] } } }, "created_at": "2026-08-31 21:02:53", "updated_at": "2026-08-31 21:02:53" }, { "invocation_id": "cad_4bfab705790e_inv_701e5e3139044f78", "idempotency_key": "9e50fb93b98c04340170bf616da89c484269fff55c2a136381b28fb960927236", "status": "finished", "result": { "result_type": "accepted", "payload": { "draft_revision": 2, "item_count": 1 } }, "created_at": "2026-08-31 21:03:05", "updated_at": "2026-08-31 21:03:05" }, { "invocation_id": "cad_4bfab705790e_inv_c7cf71863867c7dd", "idempotency_key": "73e7eef2ea2aa4f33a48a6c43a9d7fc29dd99378dd82674db78fa0a746030dfc", "status": "finished", "result": { "result_type": "accepted", "payload": { "phase": "REVIEWING_REQUIREMENTS", "draft_revision": 2 } }, "created_at": "2026-08-31 21:03:08", "updated_at": "2026-08-31 21:03:08" }, { "invocation_id": "cad_4bfab705790e_inv_c13114aaefe0f216", "idempotency_key": "e73681211a4d8694147ff111a05abe38790d40569ca1d44fcf836767572a7e6b", "status": "finished", "result": { "result_type": "accepted", "payload": { "phase": "DRAFTING_REQUIREMENTS", "review": { "schema_version": "cad.requirements-evaluation-oracle.v1", "task_id": "cad_4bfab705790e", "evaluation_only": true, "verdict": "revise", "draft_revision": 2, "reviewer_verdict": "pass", "reviewer_review_path": "documents/requirements-review-95c3c7c2c161-cad_4bfab705790e_inv_c13114aaefe.json", "item_verdicts": [ { "draft_id": "draft_001", "verdict": "revise", "reason_code": "evaluation_contract_oracle" } ], "issues": [ "The external live-evaluation contract oracle found missing executable acceptance claims." ], "missing_claims": [ { "claim_kind": "solid_count_equals", "expected": { "value": 1 } }, { "claim_kind": "bbox_rank_dimension_mm", "expected": { "rank": "minimum", "value": 10 } }, { "claim_kind": "through_cylindrical_bore", "expected": { "diameter_mm": 12, "count": 3 } } ] }, "reviewer_review_path": "documents/requirements-review-95c3c7c2c161-cad_4bfab705790e_inv_c13114aaefe.json", "evaluation_oracle": { "missing_claims": [ { "claim_kind": "solid_count_equals", "expected": { "value": 1 } }, { "claim_kind": "bbox_rank_dimension_mm", "expected": { "rank": "minimum", "value": 10 } }, { "claim_kind": "through_cylindrical_bore", "expected": { "diameter_mm": 12, "count": 3 } } ] } } }, "created_at": "2026-08-31 21:03:15", "updated_at": "2026-08-31 21:03:15" }, { "invocation_id": "cad_4bfab705790e_inv_650eedbe95afb3d7", "idempotency_key": "d8587ebcbe81b13a18733e46718d83e0ac15841d1e20ec864174db67bff51bc6", "status": "finished", "result": { "result_type": "accepted", "payload": { "draft_revision": 3, "item_count": 1 } }, "created_at": "2026-08-31 21:03:25", "updated_at": "2026-08-31 21:03:25" }, { "invocation_id": "cad_4bfab705790e_inv_a5f9a976e1c24ab3", "idempotency_key": "bc98efded9b5e1e5a0330b550fccd4b01fb3cbcdcadfdfff660958f5f81eadf7", "status": "finished", "result": { "result_type": "accepted", "payload": { "phase": "REVIEWING_REQUIREMENTS", "draft_revision": 3 } }, "created_at": "2026-08-31 21:03:29", "updated_at": "2026-08-31 21:03:29" }, { "invocation_id": "cad_4bfab705790e_inv_7f3c98543a0a62cb", "idempotency_key": "1df4ca9f7e0598900fbaee65a6a0f38f233ff8a3db1c38e7dcbad81011aa903c", "status": "finished", "result": { "result_type": "accepted", "payload": { "phase": "AWAITING_ACTION", "contract_hash": "73778b28c0f6fa21a9beab2a327b7bdb1fd87297e7439e9aa33dedd607af4336" } }, "created_at": "2026-08-31 21:03:34", "updated_at": "2026-08-31 21:03:34" }, { "invocation_id": "cad_4bfab705790e_inv_ff3ad80405460e25", "idempotency_key": "377e91d3600061778809c667b688cae2217f91e0505cd7429a867afb43d28f04", "status": "finished", "result": { "action_id": "act_010", "working_head": "cad_4bfab705790e:root:v9", "atomic_id": "extrude_add_blind", "contract_hash": "fa9ffc9fd2141453fa18a389813dde2e2ef3fb4c7ef5d05e61d51d614309e95f" }, "created_at": "2026-08-31 21:03:51", "updated_at": "2026-08-31 21:03:51" }, { "invocation_id": "cad_4bfab705790e_inv_ab9400268a4a5ac6", "idempotency_key": "b37ae573f0645968f6ea4aca608df49d43e4530022a1ecd3f376fb439747b815", "status": "finished", "result": { "candidate_id": "candidate_ceace4909e1449f0", "status": "rejected", "code": "CLAIM_VERIFICATION_FAILED", "claim_results": [ { "claim_id": "claim_001", "claim_kind": "solid_count_equals", "deterministic": true, "status": "pass", "evidence": { "solid_count": 1 } }, { "claim_id": "claim_002", "claim_kind": "bbox_rank_dimension_mm", "deterministic": true, "status": "pass", "evidence": { "rank": "minimum", "actual_mm": 10.0, "tolerance_mm": 0.1 } }, { "claim_id": "claim_003", "claim_kind": "through_cylindrical_bore", "deterministic": true, "status": "pending", "evidence": { "reason": "the target bore has not been introduced at this checkpoint" } }, { "claim_id": "claim_004", "claim_kind": "collinear_through_bore_chain", "deterministic": true, "status": "fail", "evidence": { "expected_count": 3, "actual_count": 0, "diameter_mm": 12 } }, { "claim_id": "claim_005", "claim_kind": "outer_cylindrical_surface", "deterministic": true, "status": "pending", "evidence": { "reason": "the target external cylindrical surface has not been introduced at this checkpoint" } }, { "claim_id": "claim_006", "claim_kind": "visual", "deterministic": false, "status": "pending", "evidence": { "reason": "requires independent visual review" } } ] }, "created_at": "2026-08-31 21:04:09", "updated_at": "2026-08-31 21:04:09" }, { "invocation_id": "cad_4bfab705790e_inv_6bcb6d5dccab7ddf", "idempotency_key": "8bb463c9e1d37764db46aa27f3716ff7bde4bbb60fb1157a6d8c3065d27d410c", "status": "finished", "result": { "decision": "return_to_action_selection", "phase": "AWAITING_ACTION", "working_head": "cad_4bfab705790e:root:v13" }, "created_at": "2026-08-31 21:04:16", "updated_at": "2026-08-31 21:04:16" }, { "invocation_id": "cad_4bfab705790e_inv_a1ca310d2d0d19cb", "idempotency_key": "c9ada5afd6cb5b298d1a17c2c5061ebb063a533ea1f836d02a96bed226def388", "status": "finished", "result": { "action_id": "act_014", "working_head": "cad_4bfab705790e:root:v13", "atomic_id": "revolve_add", "contract_hash": "8c0c5e842fb868cad4dc37f5d195d0d8971878bc5c23a7eb9017d829ea36c6db" }, "created_at": "2026-08-31 21:04:21", "updated_at": "2026-08-31 21:04:21" }, { "invocation_id": "cad_4bfab705790e_inv_84e81f669ad39b95", "idempotency_key": "38c09d8b35d6a7492669458924986012a28cbf0ca6c77f3fb0d80b5943acb1b5", "status": "finished", "result": { "candidate_id": "candidate_5d2c8afa51ad22d5", "status": "rejected", "code": "CLAIM_VERIFICATION_FAILED", "claim_results": [ { "claim_id": "claim_001", "claim_kind": "solid_count_equals", "deterministic": true, "status": "pass", "evidence": { "solid_count": 1 } }, { "claim_id": "claim_002", "claim_kind": "bbox_rank_dimension_mm", "deterministic": true, "status": "fail", "evidence": { "rank": "minimum", "expected_mm": 10, "actual_mm": 32.0, "tolerance_mm": 0.1 } }, { "claim_id": "claim_003", "claim_kind": "through_cylindrical_bore", "deterministic": true, "status": "pending", "evidence": { "reason": "the target bore has not been introduced at this checkpoint" } }, { "claim_id": "claim_004", "claim_kind": "collinear_through_bore_chain", "deterministic": true, "status": "fail", "evidence": { "expected_count": 3, "actual_count": 0, "diameter_mm": 12 } }, { "claim_id": "claim_005", "claim_kind": "outer_cylindrical_surface", "deterministic": true, "status": "pending", "evidence": { "reason": "the target external cylindrical-surface pattern is incomplete at this checkpoint" } }, { "claim_id": "claim_006", "claim_kind": "visual", "deterministic": false, "status": "pending", "evidence": { "reason": "requires independent visual review" } } ] }, "created_at": "2026-08-31 21:04:40", "updated_at": "2026-08-31 21:04:41" }, { "invocation_id": "cad_4bfab705790e_inv_2228edc34d609a12", "idempotency_key": "d5c4401af39dc3ba8b1927d2a71aa497e787d8f99cec5636524282e2ff8fa2d4", "status": "finished", "result": { "decision": "return_to_action_selection", "phase": "AWAITING_ACTION", "working_head": "cad_4bfab705790e:root:v17" }, "created_at": "2026-08-31 21:04:51", "updated_at": "2026-08-31 21:04:51" }, { "invocation_id": "cad_4bfab705790e_inv_f2b0d5eaeea747c6", "idempotency_key": "d3b62456c701bb522a946fb8a894bb57c1332109e0e66c829e891948c126afbc", "status": "finished", "result": { "action_id": "act_018", "working_head": "cad_4bfab705790e:root:v17", "atomic_id": "extrude_add_blind", "contract_hash": "fa9ffc9fd2141453fa18a389813dde2e2ef3fb4c7ef5d05e61d51d614309e95f" }, "created_at": "2026-08-31 21:05:02", "updated_at": "2026-08-31 21:05:02" }, { "invocation_id": "cad_4bfab705790e_inv_ae6f2c26fac2f6bd", "idempotency_key": "9d3c62246204566c3cc0f2017ea8515bc02f3f27208e12043beced3f81e39c41", "status": "finished", "result": { "candidate_id": "candidate_0cf669338f89dcea", "status": "rejected", "code": "CLAIM_VERIFICATION_FAILED", "claim_results": [ { "claim_id": "claim_001", "claim_kind": "solid_count_equals", "deterministic": true, "status": "pass", "evidence": { "solid_count": 1 } }, { "claim_id": "claim_002", "claim_kind": "bbox_rank_dimension_mm", "deterministic": true, "status": "pass", "evidence": { "rank": "minimum", "actual_mm": 10.0, "tolerance_mm": 0.1 } }, { "claim_id": "claim_003", "claim_kind": "through_cylindrical_bore", "deterministic": true, "status": "pending", "evidence": { "reason": "the target bore has not been introduced at this checkpoint" } }, { "claim_id": "claim_004", "claim_kind": "collinear_through_bore_chain", "deterministic": true, "status": "fail", "evidence": { "expected_count": 3, "actual_count": 0, "diameter_mm": 12 } }, { "claim_id": "claim_005", "claim_kind": "outer_cylindrical_surface", "deterministic": true, "status": "pending", "evidence": { "reason": "the target external cylindrical surface has not been introduced at this checkpoint" } }, { "claim_id": "claim_006", "claim_kind": "visual", "deterministic": false, "status": "pending", "evidence": { "reason": "requires independent visual review" } } ] }, "created_at": "2026-08-31 21:05:37", "updated_at": "2026-08-31 21:05:38" }, { "invocation_id": "cad_4bfab705790e_inv_e4bf0e10806f1dc5", "idempotency_key": "ffcc75cb0b540429ba711506842a13f06be2f50706b65364aa0002870d851f32", "status": "finished", "result": { "decision": "return_to_action_selection", "phase": "AWAITING_ACTION", "working_head": "cad_4bfab705790e:root:v21" }, "created_at": "2026-08-31 21:05:46", "updated_at": "2026-08-31 21:05:46" }, { "invocation_id": "cad_4bfab705790e_inv_ca9d4f8d9cb00dec", "idempotency_key": "b1a7a5a38e0ac2181e3c878c113ab27eed4c06757ccfb18a82d3bf2eeed0cde1", "status": "finished", "result": { "action_id": "act_022", "working_head": "cad_4bfab705790e:root:v21", "atomic_id": "hole_wizard", "contract_hash": "35d56dd42ee933e0fe59f9cfc33391b25844bd270a8909703af7855ad6bd25f2" }, "created_at": "2026-08-31 21:05:56", "updated_at": "2026-08-31 21:05:56" } ], "event_audit": [ { "name": "tool_call", "tool": "submit_requirements_draft_batch", "status": "success", "code": "", "raw_arguments_hash": "b31e35ced1304bbb11c4838def7ff4500590c3e1e99b19e895865819ac014511", "field_errors": [] }, { "name": "tool_call", "tool": "finalize_requirements_draft", "status": "success", "code": "", "raw_arguments_hash": "44136fa355b3678a1146ad16f7e8649e94fb4fc21fe77e8310c060f61caaff8a", "field_errors": [] }, { "name": "requirements_review", "tool": "", "status": "success", "code": "", "raw_arguments_hash": "", "field_errors": [] }, { "name": "tool_call", "tool": "patch_requirements_draft", "status": "success", "code": "", "raw_arguments_hash": "bc13ce2f9484835c5f7259723c062519ba9a7a663cc897a9db4e5e9d02079ebb", "field_errors": [] }, { "name": "tool_call", "tool": "finalize_requirements_draft", "status": "success", "code": "", "raw_arguments_hash": "44136fa355b3678a1146ad16f7e8649e94fb4fc21fe77e8310c060f61caaff8a", "field_errors": [] }, { "name": "requirements_review", "tool": "", "status": "success", "code": "", "raw_arguments_hash": "", "field_errors": [] }, { "name": "tool_call", "tool": "patch_requirements_draft", "status": "success", "code": "", "raw_arguments_hash": "8ffdc546a8f69ebcbece01c43065f1c9ba58704773bca18c8eba8e8f3ea0999f", "field_errors": [] }, { "name": "tool_call", "tool": "finalize_requirements_draft", "status": "success", "code": "", "raw_arguments_hash": "44136fa355b3678a1146ad16f7e8649e94fb4fc21fe77e8310c060f61caaff8a", "field_errors": [] }, { "name": "requirements_review", "tool": "", "status": "success", "code": "", "raw_arguments_hash": "", "field_errors": [] }, { "name": "action_selection", "tool": "propose_next_action", "status": "success", "code": "", "raw_arguments_hash": "51e4c49dbe54ef49e71a9a44fb546f20fc0c135830fcb7ea76830fd7e9eee144", "field_errors": [] }, { "name": "tool_call", "tool": "get_cdsl_operation_contract", "status": "success", "code": "", "raw_arguments_hash": "8792f2d3dc4c687bb8f502cac0cacf8c60bef8fac8fa6235e4687a33e6e4fd75", "field_errors": [] }, { "name": "candidate_result", "tool": "submit_cdsl_fragment", "status": "error", "code": "CLAIM_VERIFICATION_FAILED", "raw_arguments_hash": "42aec572c7689d24779f1a498d27d6d30615e0462820ec31d3972d0dcab0332f", "field_errors": [] }, { "name": "tool_call", "tool": "record_geometry_conclusion", "status": "success", "code": "", "raw_arguments_hash": "ad06f696f825bc76ec5beae83f2d0c36049bb363b8e4b919be531f671858908d", "field_errors": [] }, { "name": "action_selection", "tool": "propose_next_action", "status": "success", "code": "", "raw_arguments_hash": "714858e585787d8283e7f2ca4a43c2dd2342ee0661bc62e9d475adc262043023", "field_errors": [] }, { "name": "tool_call", "tool": "get_cdsl_operation_contract", "status": "success", "code": "", "raw_arguments_hash": "3eb5ffb0825869c6d02cb5475ef7a3eed6043fb3427e246f7cadae36116f344f", "field_errors": [] }, { "name": "candidate_result", "tool": "submit_cdsl_fragment", "status": "error", "code": "CLAIM_VERIFICATION_FAILED", "raw_arguments_hash": "f7e84c1b32337c677d467a7c2c742c6ded4fed9324d31b55fc37a3a0df7b0ea2", "field_errors": [] }, { "name": "tool_call", "tool": "record_geometry_conclusion", "status": "success", "code": "", "raw_arguments_hash": "a90fb6f6cb1bace0d7e018750410d017c76e7632f34ba57d58003e07b095041d", "field_errors": [] }, { "name": "action_selection", "tool": "propose_next_action", "status": "success", "code": "", "raw_arguments_hash": "c6eb3866e3884ac9f06c7e71ba29ad314e9c4dd5550855bc2f1950f7f976b6c5", "field_errors": [] }, { "name": "tool_call", "tool": "get_cdsl_operation_contract", "status": "success", "code": "", "raw_arguments_hash": "974e4909e81a1042ff09a6b0643ffc31564486ff77edd853617dddd29ce788e3", "field_errors": [] }, { "name": "candidate_result", "tool": "submit_cdsl_fragment", "status": "error", "code": "CLAIM_VERIFICATION_FAILED", "raw_arguments_hash": "056770517833658fa72bc0e1861ed7f0de751a4032f779ebde8c819f3d3f4c6c", "field_errors": [] }, { "name": "tool_call", "tool": "record_geometry_conclusion", "status": "success", "code": "", "raw_arguments_hash": "e2b6b67fcc6b745be979924e38eab922c1335da811c2e9d14abefb5fbe74480a", "field_errors": [] }, { "name": "action_selection", "tool": "propose_next_action", "status": "success", "code": "", "raw_arguments_hash": "52d1ef989302ea6123acd02649eeae532f376da48bde3642593350f6016b3d50", "field_errors": [] }, { "name": "tool_call", "tool": "get_cdsl_operation_contract", "status": "success", "code": "", "raw_arguments_hash": "3467e359229c7accc64be605b3c082f429a4ef0597c789225972c9087a900320", "field_errors": [] }, { "name": "tool_call", "tool": "inspect_topology", "status": "success", "code": "", "raw_arguments_hash": "7158eb578f1a9e7dfb9c82cbb3db1d3a9614a78c0503d02e8f977a96dd451911", "field_errors": [] }, { "name": "candidate_result", "tool": "submit_cdsl_fragment", "status": "error", "code": "AUTHOR_FORMAT_INVALID", "raw_arguments_hash": "b7d9ae25ca6416c848c8f2345de31e6ffcee4d6f3fb0b0fb6b592ee5d78c0982", "field_errors": [ { "path": "/feature/selector_tokens/0", "message": "'' is not one of []" } ] }, { "name": "candidate_result", "tool": "submit_cdsl_fragment", "status": "error", "code": "AUTHOR_FORMAT_INVALID", "raw_arguments_hash": "c3e222ef4310fa1ab0a4ab8744e94974a11c9fcd0e2d781f1186dc5790883d66", "field_errors": [ { "path": "/feature/selector_tokens/0", "message": "'root' is not one of []" } ] }, { "name": "candidate_result", "tool": "submit_cdsl_fragment", "status": "error", "code": "AUTHOR_FORMAT_INVALID", "raw_arguments_hash": "15140c7cf9135d6822f50207cdaab857389a85eaff524ec8a5ff1b02129fe21c", "field_errors": [ { "path": "/feature/selector_tokens/0", "message": "'root' is not one of []" } ] }, { "name": "task_terminal", "tool": "submit_cdsl_fragment", "status": "", "code": "FAILED_AUTHOR_FORMAT", "raw_arguments_hash": "", "field_errors": [] } ] } ], "suite": "comprehensive", "require_live": true, "report_root": "/Users/lk/Projects/cdsl-cad/backend/live-evals/20260831T205806Z" }