{
  "status": "failed",
  "author": {
    "provider": "openai",
    "model": "gpt-5.4-mini"
  },
  "author_request_identity": {
    "provider": "openai",
    "model": "gpt-5.4-mini",
    "api_style": "responses",
    "reasoning_effort": "medium",
    "sampling": {
      "temperature": null
    }
  },
  "reviewer": {
    "provider": "openai",
    "model": "gpt-5.5"
  },
  "author_capability": {
    "schema_hash": "3935c6f40d3b8b9bb7c5672cdea37049a3cd9eb57c9f722b738397a45d77490c",
    "tool_count": 28,
    "supported": true,
    "failures": [],
    "usage": {
      "prompt_tokens": 133729,
      "completion_tokens": 3822
    },
    "mode": "openai_compatible_tool_calling",
    "probe_unavailable": false
  },
  "reviewer_capability": {
    "schema_hash": "3935c6f40d3b8b9bb7c5672cdea37049a3cd9eb57c9f722b738397a45d77490c",
    "tool_count": 28,
    "supported": true,
    "failures": [],
    "usage": {
      "prompt_tokens": 133729,
      "completion_tokens": 1667
    },
    "mode": "openai_compatible_tool_calling",
    "probe_unavailable": false
  },
  "structured_output_mode": {
    "author": "openai_compatible_tool_calling",
    "reviewer": "openai_compatible_tool_calling"
  },
  "git_revision": "7533b298f1a23ed5d4c8a63982b2984258426b52",
  "protocol_version": "3.0",
  "runtime_profile_sha256": "bc2e2110a49929d96ad1e0d1996b2579ff1b56c80fd822423107bee7e560187e",
  "operation_contracts": [
    {
      "atomic_id": "chamfer",
      "contract_hash": "eb5d3b87d055edf18fd8d7398cd104f5edf2bb9ae6994fc5eb870a3ab685d678",
      "contract_version": "3.0",
      "registry_revision": "1.3.1"
    },
    {
      "atomic_id": "extrude_add_blind",
      "contract_hash": "fa9ffc9fd2141453fa18a389813dde2e2ef3fb4c7ef5d05e61d51d614309e95f",
      "contract_version": "3.0",
      "registry_revision": "1.3.1"
    },
    {
      "atomic_id": "extrude_add_two_sided",
      "contract_hash": "35de3efa8ec4d4a1a37904f0c34084bb3fd2da07fa479a2b6d35e4837b210e9d",
      "contract_version": "3.0",
      "registry_revision": "1.3.1"
    },
    {
      "atomic_id": "extrude_cut_blind",
      "contract_hash": "fe00ac225362469afe00cd4aee9b48259e8ceb74aa11d9a54ff038c6d12f0d50",
      "contract_version": "3.0",
      "registry_revision": "1.3.1"
    },
    {
      "atomic_id": "fillet",
      "contract_hash": "db31dd9c749707cc9453fc248d7ca86ef4faaaf15376a40bd659c325b037c878",
      "contract_version": "3.0",
      "registry_revision": "1.3.1"
    },
    {
      "atomic_id": "hole_blind",
      "contract_hash": "f62e12603feeca6d7e83acdab651fcb023e08a46c39fd1509e9dcb81d4f0c721",
      "contract_version": "3.0",
      "registry_revision": "1.3.1"
    },
    {
      "atomic_id": "hole_counterbore",
      "contract_hash": "15a56094125780177ad75040d160430cc9f0a97928214bd0553acddfbff9aa16",
      "contract_version": "3.0",
      "registry_revision": "1.3.1"
    },
    {
      "atomic_id": "hole_countersink",
      "contract_hash": "84b98d26d2a836105cf383bdfb1e733ea16bfa41935a08a48cf5c4d6c71ad49f",
      "contract_version": "3.0",
      "registry_revision": "1.3.1"
    },
    {
      "atomic_id": "hole_wizard",
      "contract_hash": "35d56dd42ee933e0fe59f9cfc33391b25844bd270a8909703af7855ad6bd25f2",
      "contract_version": "3.0",
      "registry_revision": "1.3.1"
    },
    {
      "atomic_id": "pattern_linear",
      "contract_hash": "ecf393713de82ac30ca326719774ed8315030d9d980d1370c95003505ce28471",
      "contract_version": "3.0",
      "registry_revision": "1.3.1"
    },
    {
      "atomic_id": "pattern_mirror",
      "contract_hash": "ec014e6c1639d98e2a50a26c88256ad0a9ad0fd8a027cd57b710c07d8bf3ecb8",
      "contract_version": "3.0",
      "registry_revision": "1.3.1"
    },
    {
      "atomic_id": "reference_axis",
      "contract_hash": "2ebeda16a1fc50aefb0fa923794f43e609aca07dbd5059968824dfcf97532aaa",
      "contract_version": "3.0",
      "registry_revision": "1.3.1"
    },
    {
      "atomic_id": "reference_plane",
      "contract_hash": "86968365856f972fdacef1a739be379458a563be5763c97d4f18e6b93d14ef55",
      "contract_version": "3.0",
      "registry_revision": "1.3.1"
    },
    {
      "atomic_id": "revolve_add",
      "contract_hash": "8c0c5e842fb868cad4dc37f5d195d0d8971878bc5c23a7eb9017d829ea36c6db",
      "contract_version": "3.0",
      "registry_revision": "1.3.1"
    },
    {
      "atomic_id": "revolve_cut",
      "contract_hash": "101c9d285c46cf8c6d3bba516cde2bf9002eee0e9cc62d66cade676c3a71db56",
      "contract_version": "3.0",
      "registry_revision": "1.3.1"
    },
    {
      "atomic_id": "sphere_add",
      "contract_hash": "ef855cadd1f295b16ebbf11538557efaf790ff0c44262c9ae61e769242844c95",
      "contract_version": "3.0",
      "registry_revision": "1.3.1"
    }
  ],
  "verifier_registry_version": "cad.verifier-registry.v1",
  "verifier_schema_hash": "7a05abe600903feabb57bc8c77e26042c28ca13fe5d5caeb94f37351ce8adf97",
  "token_comparison": {
    "schema_version": "cad.token-comparison.v1",
    "status": "not_required"
  },
  "baseline_report": "",
  "results": [
    {
      "scenario": "three_hole_linkage",
      "repetition": 1,
      "success": false,
      "outcome": "failed",
      "started_at": "2026-08-31T21:33:15.791574+00:00",
      "finished_at": "2026-08-31T21:35:04.607001+00:00",
      "duration_ms": 108815,
      "terminal": {
        "taskId": "cad_61118b0b03ba",
        "lifecycle": "waiting_for_user",
        "code": "WAITING_FOR_USER",
        "message": "Requirements review limit reached; a user decision is required."
      },
      "projection": {
        "schema_version": "3.0",
        "task_id": "cad_61118b0b03ba",
        "phase": "WAITING_FOR_USER",
        "lifecycle": "waiting_for_user",
        "state_version": 10,
        "active_revision": "",
        "current_revision": "",
        "published_revision": "",
        "pending_action": null,
        "active_candidate_id": "",
        "repair_required": false,
        "last_error": "WAITING_FOR_USER",
        "retry_from_phase": "",
        "requirements_draft_path": "documents/requirements-draft-v3-1e78fc5e001e-cad_61118b0b03ba_inv_c4f29c79aef.json",
        "requirements_review_path": "documents/requirements-review-95eef23b7115-cad_61118b0b03ba_inv_ba791c6e359.json",
        "requirements_contract_path": "",
        "action_ledger_summary": [
          {
            "sequence": 1,
            "at": "2026-08-31 21:33:29",
            "draft_path": "documents/requirements-draft-v1-9569137a152d-cad_61118b0b03ba_inv_cbe0d9057fa.json",
            "draft_revision": 1,
            "event": "requirements_draft_updated",
            "invocation_id": "cad_61118b0b03ba_inv_cbe0d9057fa9c392",
            "item_count": 7
          },
          {
            "sequence": 2,
            "at": "2026-08-31 21:33:34",
            "draft_revision": 1,
            "event": "requirements_review_requested",
            "invocation_id": "cad_61118b0b03ba_inv_06bbea193838a2fc"
          },
          {
            "sequence": 3,
            "at": "2026-08-31 21:33:57",
            "event": "requirements_review_revise",
            "invocation_id": "cad_61118b0b03ba_inv_e2c8d7369fe13f8e",
            "review_path": "documents/requirements-review-ad5c325ac148-cad_61118b0b03ba_inv_e2c8d7369fe.json"
          },
          {
            "sequence": 4,
            "at": "2026-08-31 21:34:09",
            "draft_path": "documents/requirements-draft-v2-61b42ee7c0c5-cad_61118b0b03ba_inv_d94f7195643.json",
            "draft_revision": 2,
            "event": "requirements_draft_patched",
            "invocation_id": "cad_61118b0b03ba_inv_d94f71956434ed71",
            "item_count": 7
          },
          {
            "sequence": 5,
            "at": "2026-08-31 21:34:12",
            "draft_revision": 2,
            "event": "requirements_review_requested",
            "invocation_id": "cad_61118b0b03ba_inv_c7caf81afa71f667"
          },
          {
            "sequence": 6,
            "at": "2026-08-31 21:34:19",
            "event": "requirements_evaluation_oracle_revise",
            "invocation_id": "cad_61118b0b03ba_inv_576f30faa568cb0c",
            "missing_claims": [
              {
                "claim_kind": "collinear_through_bore_chain",
                "expected": {
                  "adjacent_distances_mm": [
                    60,
                    80
                  ],
                  "diameter_mm": 12,
                  "tolerance_mm": 0.1
                }
              }
            ],
            "oracle_path": "documents/evaluation-contract-oracle-e9f00ebbf0e1.json",
            "review_path": "documents/requirements-review-83c51572391b-cad_61118b0b03ba_inv_576f30faa56.json"
          },
          {
            "sequence": 7,
            "at": "2026-08-31 21:34:36",
            "draft_path": "documents/requirements-draft-v3-1e78fc5e001e-cad_61118b0b03ba_inv_c4f29c79aef.json",
            "draft_revision": 3,
            "event": "requirements_draft_patched",
            "invocation_id": "cad_61118b0b03ba_inv_c4f29c79aef5c797",
            "item_count": 7
          },
          {
            "sequence": 8,
            "at": "2026-08-31 21:34:40",
            "draft_revision": 3,
            "event": "requirements_review_requested",
            "invocation_id": "cad_61118b0b03ba_inv_2443bcac857a1442"
          },
          {
            "sequence": 9,
            "at": "2026-08-31 21:35:04",
            "event": "requirements_review_revise",
            "invocation_id": "cad_61118b0b03ba_inv_ba791c6e359e7a0c",
            "review_path": "documents/requirements-review-95eef23b7115-cad_61118b0b03ba_inv_ba791c6e359.json"
          },
          {
            "sequence": 10,
            "at": "2026-08-31 21:35:04",
            "draft_revision": 3,
            "event": "requirements_review_limit_reached"
          }
        ],
        "revisions": []
      },
      "usage": {
        "calls": 11,
        "prompt_tokens": 68755,
        "completion_tokens": 4585,
        "context_chars": 52489,
        "records": [
          {
            "cache_hit": false,
            "completion_tokens": 774,
            "context_chars": 738,
            "model_id": "gpt-5.4-mini",
            "prompt_tokens": 6103,
            "provider_id": "openai",
            "raw_arguments_hash": "8fbb73db04f9d70dd7e37dc17b29a9769f032e019356f8854d89eb0e9e82323c",
            "retry_reason": "",
            "tool": "submit_requirements_draft_batch",
            "total_tokens": 6877,
            "usage_available": true
          },
          {
            "cache_hit": false,
            "completion_tokens": 120,
            "context_chars": 4428,
            "model_id": "gpt-5.4-mini",
            "prompt_tokens": 5614,
            "provider_id": "openai",
            "raw_arguments_hash": "44136fa355b3678a1146ad16f7e8649e94fb4fc21fe77e8310c060f61caaff8a",
            "retry_reason": "",
            "tool": "finalize_requirements_draft",
            "total_tokens": 5734,
            "usage_available": true
          },
          {
            "cache_hit": false,
            "completion_tokens": 258,
            "context_chars": 5106,
            "model_id": "gpt-5.5",
            "prompt_tokens": 6079,
            "provider_id": "openai",
            "raw_arguments_hash": "cf6c2f9e01e7bd94362e092964f28710a1b5c3434fbafad5751029456d8b80e6",
            "retry_reason": "",
            "role": "reviewer",
            "tool": "review_requirements",
            "total_tokens": 6337,
            "usage_available": true
          },
          {
            "cache_hit": false,
            "completion_tokens": 663,
            "context_chars": 5545,
            "model_id": "gpt-5.5",
            "prompt_tokens": 6175,
            "provider_id": "openai",
            "raw_arguments_hash": "a435608eaedeadc4928fde0cc5dda4c2a3ce9b87de7eea978531fdeadef44c67",
            "retry_reason": "",
            "role": "reviewer",
            "tool": "review_requirements",
            "total_tokens": 6838,
            "usage_available": true
          },
          {
            "cache_hit": false,
            "completion_tokens": 640,
            "context_chars": 6624,
            "model_id": "gpt-5.4-mini",
            "prompt_tokens": 7782,
            "provider_id": "openai",
            "raw_arguments_hash": "6193c963abbf512fa5e35a8341c03519eaac38c4625873d564d2bc296267c724",
            "retry_reason": "",
            "tool": "patch_requirements_draft",
            "total_tokens": 8422,
            "usage_available": true
          },
          {
            "cache_hit": false,
            "completion_tokens": 18,
            "context_chars": 4281,
            "model_id": "gpt-5.4-mini",
            "prompt_tokens": 5566,
            "provider_id": "openai",
            "raw_arguments_hash": "44136fa355b3678a1146ad16f7e8649e94fb4fc21fe77e8310c060f61caaff8a",
            "retry_reason": "",
            "tool": "finalize_requirements_draft",
            "total_tokens": 5584,
            "usage_available": true
          },
          {
            "cache_hit": false,
            "completion_tokens": 221,
            "context_chars": 4973,
            "model_id": "gpt-5.5",
            "prompt_tokens": 6031,
            "provider_id": "openai",
            "raw_arguments_hash": "7b225d8587ad1f268c063230c59fdac1a294758f12328af9d0315046acb5b2a1",
            "retry_reason": "",
            "role": "reviewer",
            "tool": "review_requirements",
            "total_tokens": 6252,
            "usage_available": true
          },
          {
            "cache_hit": false,
            "completion_tokens": 922,
            "context_chars": 6143,
            "model_id": "gpt-5.4-mini",
            "prompt_tokens": 7681,
            "provider_id": "openai",
            "raw_arguments_hash": "8d1b6e26d94c397559dc1df3462b2d3ae1c3bee2849bde8deee99e0617c14301",
            "retry_reason": "",
            "tool": "patch_requirements_draft",
            "total_tokens": 8603,
            "usage_available": true
          },
          {
            "cache_hit": false,
            "completion_tokens": 82,
            "context_chars": 4276,
            "model_id": "gpt-5.4-mini",
            "prompt_tokens": 5566,
            "provider_id": "openai",
            "raw_arguments_hash": "44136fa355b3678a1146ad16f7e8649e94fb4fc21fe77e8310c060f61caaff8a",
            "retry_reason": "",
            "tool": "finalize_requirements_draft",
            "total_tokens": 5648,
            "usage_available": true
          },
          {
            "cache_hit": false,
            "completion_tokens": 262,
            "context_chars": 4968,
            "model_id": "gpt-5.5",
            "prompt_tokens": 6031,
            "provider_id": "openai",
            "raw_arguments_hash": "8f9388eb00532e29c7ea722eb4b27a5f65c1b2b9d72948c2b153e4f473a74f31",
            "retry_reason": "",
            "role": "reviewer",
            "tool": "review_requirements",
            "total_tokens": 6293,
            "usage_available": true
          },
          {
            "cache_hit": false,
            "completion_tokens": 625,
            "context_chars": 5407,
            "model_id": "gpt-5.5",
            "prompt_tokens": 6127,
            "provider_id": "openai",
            "raw_arguments_hash": "df0a30724f7a0e8f6bfaa7d05655b84aa6a59864fb03ef0352fd434f3332c19e",
            "retry_reason": "",
            "role": "reviewer",
            "tool": "review_requirements",
            "total_tokens": 6752,
            "usage_available": true
          }
        ]
      },
      "checks": {
        "expected_terminal_phase": false,
        "token_budget": true,
        "call_budget": true,
        "author_turn_budget": true,
        "reviewer_turn_budget": true,
        "required_claims": false,
        "acceptance_contract_coverage": false,
        "required_operations": false,
        "required_operation_alternative": false,
        "immutable_artifacts": false,
        "required_artifact_evidence": false,
        "artifact_manifest": true,
        "action_ledger": true,
        "unique_revisions": true,
        "deterministic_claims_pass": false,
        "raw_argument_audit": true,
        "no_schema_or_decision_rejections": false
      },
      "acceptance_coverage": {
        "required_claim_kinds": [
          "bbox_rank_dimension_mm",
          "collinear_through_bore_chain",
          "solid_count_equals",
          "through_cylindrical_bore",
          "visual"
        ],
        "covered_claim_kinds": [],
        "required_claims": [
          {
            "claim_kind": "solid_count_equals",
            "expected": {
              "value": 1
            }
          },
          {
            "claim_kind": "bbox_rank_dimension_mm",
            "expected": {
              "rank": "minimum",
              "value": 10
            }
          },
          {
            "claim_kind": "through_cylindrical_bore",
            "expected": {
              "diameter_mm": 12,
              "count": 3
            }
          },
          {
            "claim_kind": "collinear_through_bore_chain",
            "expected": {
              "diameter_mm": 12,
              "adjacent_distances_mm": [
                60,
                80
              ],
              "tolerance_mm": 0.1
            }
          },
          {
            "claim_kind": "visual",
            "expected": {}
          }
        ],
        "missing_claims": [
          {
            "claim_kind": "solid_count_equals",
            "expected": {
              "value": 1
            }
          },
          {
            "claim_kind": "bbox_rank_dimension_mm",
            "expected": {
              "rank": "minimum",
              "value": 10
            }
          },
          {
            "claim_kind": "through_cylindrical_bore",
            "expected": {
              "diameter_mm": 12,
              "count": 3
            }
          },
          {
            "claim_kind": "collinear_through_bore_chain",
            "expected": {
              "diameter_mm": 12,
              "adjacent_distances_mm": [
                60,
                80
              ],
              "tolerance_mm": 0.1
            }
          },
          {
            "claim_kind": "visual",
            "expected": {}
          }
        ],
        "validation_capability_gaps": [
          {
            "id": "linkage_outer_circles",
            "description": "32 mm outer circles with smoothly connected segments"
          }
        ],
        "complete": false
      },
      "failure_attribution": {
        "layer": "model_format_or_decision",
        "reason_code": "AUTHOR_FORMAT_INVALID",
        "evidence_codes": [
          "AUTHOR_FORMAT_INVALID",
          "WAITING_FOR_USER"
        ],
        "failed_checks": [
          "expected_terminal_phase",
          "required_claims",
          "acceptance_contract_coverage",
          "required_operations",
          "required_operation_alternative",
          "immutable_artifacts",
          "required_artifact_evidence",
          "deterministic_claims_pass",
          "no_schema_or_decision_rejections"
        ]
      },
      "rejection_codes": [
        "AUTHOR_FORMAT_INVALID",
        "AUTHOR_FORMAT_INVALID"
      ],
      "schema_rejection_count": 2,
      "retry_count": 2,
      "rollback_count": 0,
      "candidate_ids": [],
      "revision_ids": [],
      "final_claim_results": [],
      "redacted_correlation_ids": [
        "36c10a2456241ab335db",
        "471b5dc2e6d8f6fe3f09",
        "91c9bb6407a468a4a83b",
        "0a01e51e65bc8c10cd4c",
        "ee3ecfd2549b57452a56",
        "9aad4de9aeb8e2f4211f",
        "e64a2c2e1177a13c338b",
        "4c3eb8a266c1dfe574ff",
        "ffd7ab6fe688f66e6408"
      ],
      "tool_audits": [
        {
          "audit_id": 1,
          "at": "2026-08-31 21:33:29",
          "actor": "author",
          "tool": "submit_requirements_draft_batch",
          "raw_arguments_hash": "8fbb73db04f9d70dd7e37dc17b29a9769f032e019356f8854d89eb0e9e82323c",
          "canonical_schema_valid": true,
          "field_errors": [],
          "state_binding": {
            "active_revision": "",
            "binding_valid": true,
            "contract_hash": "",
            "contract_hash_current": true,
            "expected_working_head": "cad_61118b0b03ba:root:v0",
            "phase": "DRAFTING_REQUIREMENTS",
            "selector_snapshot_id": "",
            "supplied_working_head": "",
            "working_head": "cad_61118b0b03ba:root:v0",
            "working_head_binding_source": "current_state",
            "working_head_matches": true
          },
          "returned_tool": "submit_requirements_draft_batch",
          "single_allowed_call": true
        },
        {
          "audit_id": 2,
          "at": "2026-08-31 21:33:34",
          "actor": "author",
          "tool": "finalize_requirements_draft",
          "raw_arguments_hash": "44136fa355b3678a1146ad16f7e8649e94fb4fc21fe77e8310c060f61caaff8a",
          "canonical_schema_valid": true,
          "field_errors": [],
          "state_binding": {
            "active_revision": "",
            "binding_valid": true,
            "contract_hash": "",
            "contract_hash_current": true,
            "expected_working_head": "cad_61118b0b03ba:root:v1",
            "phase": "DRAFTING_REQUIREMENTS",
            "selector_snapshot_id": "",
            "supplied_working_head": "",
            "working_head": "cad_61118b0b03ba:root:v1",
            "working_head_binding_source": "current_state",
            "working_head_matches": true
          },
          "returned_tool": "finalize_requirements_draft",
          "single_allowed_call": true
        },
        {
          "audit_id": 3,
          "at": "2026-08-31 21:33:42",
          "actor": "reviewer",
          "tool": "review_requirements",
          "raw_arguments_hash": "cf6c2f9e01e7bd94362e092964f28710a1b5c3434fbafad5751029456d8b80e6",
          "canonical_schema_valid": true,
          "field_errors": [],
          "state_binding": {
            "active_revision": "",
            "binding_valid": true,
            "contract_hash": "",
            "contract_hash_current": true,
            "expected_working_head": "cad_61118b0b03ba:root:v2",
            "phase": "REVIEWING_REQUIREMENTS",
            "selector_snapshot_id": "",
            "supplied_working_head": "",
            "working_head": "cad_61118b0b03ba:root:v2",
            "working_head_binding_source": "current_state",
            "working_head_matches": true
          },
          "returned_tool": "review_requirements",
          "single_allowed_call": true
        },
        {
          "audit_id": 4,
          "at": "2026-08-31 21:33:57",
          "actor": "reviewer",
          "tool": "review_requirements",
          "raw_arguments_hash": "a435608eaedeadc4928fde0cc5dda4c2a3ce9b87de7eea978531fdeadef44c67",
          "canonical_schema_valid": true,
          "field_errors": [],
          "state_binding": {
            "active_revision": "",
            "binding_valid": true,
            "contract_hash": "",
            "contract_hash_current": true,
            "expected_working_head": "cad_61118b0b03ba:root:v2",
            "phase": "REVIEWING_REQUIREMENTS",
            "selector_snapshot_id": "",
            "supplied_working_head": "",
            "working_head": "cad_61118b0b03ba:root:v2",
            "working_head_binding_source": "current_state",
            "working_head_matches": true
          },
          "returned_tool": "review_requirements",
          "single_allowed_call": true
        },
        {
          "audit_id": 5,
          "at": "2026-08-31 21:34:09",
          "actor": "author",
          "tool": "patch_requirements_draft",
          "raw_arguments_hash": "6193c963abbf512fa5e35a8341c03519eaac38c4625873d564d2bc296267c724",
          "canonical_schema_valid": true,
          "field_errors": [],
          "state_binding": {
            "active_revision": "",
            "binding_valid": true,
            "contract_hash": "",
            "contract_hash_current": true,
            "expected_working_head": "cad_61118b0b03ba:root:v3",
            "phase": "DRAFTING_REQUIREMENTS",
            "selector_snapshot_id": "",
            "supplied_working_head": "",
            "working_head": "cad_61118b0b03ba:root:v3",
            "working_head_binding_source": "current_state",
            "working_head_matches": true
          },
          "returned_tool": "patch_requirements_draft",
          "single_allowed_call": true
        },
        {
          "audit_id": 6,
          "at": "2026-08-31 21:34:11",
          "actor": "author",
          "tool": "finalize_requirements_draft",
          "raw_arguments_hash": "44136fa355b3678a1146ad16f7e8649e94fb4fc21fe77e8310c060f61caaff8a",
          "canonical_schema_valid": true,
          "field_errors": [],
          "state_binding": {
            "active_revision": "",
            "binding_valid": true,
            "contract_hash": "",
            "contract_hash_current": true,
            "expected_working_head": "cad_61118b0b03ba:root:v4",
            "phase": "DRAFTING_REQUIREMENTS",
            "selector_snapshot_id": "",
            "supplied_working_head": "",
            "working_head": "cad_61118b0b03ba:root:v4",
            "working_head_binding_source": "current_state",
            "working_head_matches": true
          },
          "returned_tool": "finalize_requirements_draft",
          "single_allowed_call": true
        },
        {
          "audit_id": 7,
          "at": "2026-08-31 21:34:19",
          "actor": "reviewer",
          "tool": "review_requirements",
          "raw_arguments_hash": "7b225d8587ad1f268c063230c59fdac1a294758f12328af9d0315046acb5b2a1",
          "canonical_schema_valid": true,
          "field_errors": [],
          "state_binding": {
            "active_revision": "",
            "binding_valid": true,
            "contract_hash": "",
            "contract_hash_current": true,
            "expected_working_head": "cad_61118b0b03ba:root:v5",
            "phase": "REVIEWING_REQUIREMENTS",
            "selector_snapshot_id": "",
            "supplied_working_head": "",
            "working_head": "cad_61118b0b03ba:root:v5",
            "working_head_binding_source": "current_state",
            "working_head_matches": true
          },
          "returned_tool": "review_requirements",
          "single_allowed_call": true
        },
        {
          "audit_id": 8,
          "at": "2026-08-31 21:34:36",
          "actor": "author",
          "tool": "patch_requirements_draft",
          "raw_arguments_hash": "8d1b6e26d94c397559dc1df3462b2d3ae1c3bee2849bde8deee99e0617c14301",
          "canonical_schema_valid": true,
          "field_errors": [],
          "state_binding": {
            "active_revision": "",
            "binding_valid": true,
            "contract_hash": "",
            "contract_hash_current": true,
            "expected_working_head": "cad_61118b0b03ba:root:v6",
            "phase": "DRAFTING_REQUIREMENTS",
            "selector_snapshot_id": "",
            "supplied_working_head": "",
            "working_head": "cad_61118b0b03ba:root:v6",
            "working_head_binding_source": "current_state",
            "working_head_matches": true
          },
          "returned_tool": "patch_requirements_draft",
          "single_allowed_call": true
        },
        {
          "audit_id": 9,
          "at": "2026-08-31 21:34:40",
          "actor": "author",
          "tool": "finalize_requirements_draft",
          "raw_arguments_hash": "44136fa355b3678a1146ad16f7e8649e94fb4fc21fe77e8310c060f61caaff8a",
          "canonical_schema_valid": true,
          "field_errors": [],
          "state_binding": {
            "active_revision": "",
            "binding_valid": true,
            "contract_hash": "",
            "contract_hash_current": true,
            "expected_working_head": "cad_61118b0b03ba:root:v7",
            "phase": "DRAFTING_REQUIREMENTS",
            "selector_snapshot_id": "",
            "supplied_working_head": "",
            "working_head": "cad_61118b0b03ba:root:v7",
            "working_head_binding_source": "current_state",
            "working_head_matches": true
          },
          "returned_tool": "finalize_requirements_draft",
          "single_allowed_call": true
        },
        {
          "audit_id": 10,
          "at": "2026-08-31 21:34:47",
          "actor": "reviewer",
          "tool": "review_requirements",
          "raw_arguments_hash": "8f9388eb00532e29c7ea722eb4b27a5f65c1b2b9d72948c2b153e4f473a74f31",
          "canonical_schema_valid": true,
          "field_errors": [],
          "state_binding": {
            "active_revision": "",
            "binding_valid": true,
            "contract_hash": "",
            "contract_hash_current": true,
            "expected_working_head": "cad_61118b0b03ba:root:v8",
            "phase": "REVIEWING_REQUIREMENTS",
            "selector_snapshot_id": "",
            "supplied_working_head": "",
            "working_head": "cad_61118b0b03ba:root:v8",
            "working_head_binding_source": "current_state",
            "working_head_matches": true
          },
          "returned_tool": "review_requirements",
          "single_allowed_call": true
        },
        {
          "audit_id": 11,
          "at": "2026-08-31 21:35:04",
          "actor": "reviewer",
          "tool": "review_requirements",
          "raw_arguments_hash": "df0a30724f7a0e8f6bfaa7d05655b84aa6a59864fb03ef0352fd434f3332c19e",
          "canonical_schema_valid": true,
          "field_errors": [],
          "state_binding": {
            "active_revision": "",
            "binding_valid": true,
            "contract_hash": "",
            "contract_hash_current": true,
            "expected_working_head": "cad_61118b0b03ba:root:v8",
            "phase": "REVIEWING_REQUIREMENTS",
            "selector_snapshot_id": "",
            "supplied_working_head": "",
            "working_head": "cad_61118b0b03ba:root:v8",
            "working_head_binding_source": "current_state",
            "working_head_matches": true
          },
          "returned_tool": "review_requirements",
          "single_allowed_call": true
        }
      ],
      "artifact_root": "/Users/lk/Projects/cdsl-cad/backend/live-evals/20260831T212855Z/artifacts/cad_61118b0b03ba",
      "action_ledger_path": "/Users/lk/Projects/cdsl-cad/backend/live-evals/20260831T212855Z/artifacts/cad_61118b0b03ba/actions/action-ledger.jsonl",
      "artifact_manifest": {
        "schema_version": "cad.live-eval-artifact-manifest.v1",
        "artifact_root": "/Users/lk/Projects/cdsl-cad/backend/live-evals/20260831T212855Z/artifacts/cad_61118b0b03ba",
        "files": [
          {
            "path": "actions/action-ledger.jsonl",
            "sha256": "c1c99d4e2f54d9958889c3e5fd4deb7f4af3bcda799d8800d1b5eebecfd14a9e"
          },
          {
            "path": "documents/requirements-draft-v1-9569137a152d-cad_61118b0b03ba_inv_cbe0d9057fa.json",
            "sha256": "d82a1140cda227024f98bbcbf637ca8ebd505afad1404fc31d49075ae0fd645d"
          },
          {
            "path": "documents/requirements-draft-v2-61b42ee7c0c5-cad_61118b0b03ba_inv_d94f7195643.json",
            "sha256": "13d99d23d666778ec80d2641d5c40dab90efd70820138ed509bf28c9403165a4"
          },
          {
            "path": "documents/requirements-draft-v3-1e78fc5e001e-cad_61118b0b03ba_inv_c4f29c79aef.json",
            "sha256": "3eee160a4e523da910d889436b98fa0de98b29273b25bd62f5e2c455a05d9b7d"
          },
          {
            "path": "documents/requirements-review-83c51572391b-cad_61118b0b03ba_inv_576f30faa56.json",
            "sha256": "992d1e9318e9703f0ae4f1433f42ba6010d6996dcf08620d2cbd61cce9605bc4"
          },
          {
            "path": "documents/requirements-review-95eef23b7115-cad_61118b0b03ba_inv_ba791c6e359.json",
            "sha256": "f8dc0671dcdaf0bd9932e6181105fae271cf07c3ee811b36f04722fe6b1c877c"
          },
          {
            "path": "documents/requirements-review-ad5c325ac148-cad_61118b0b03ba_inv_e2c8d7369fe.json",
            "sha256": "5c2cfdcea313a64f38d4dbc29eb51f35bcbb9b0442befd55c2515d33b52085b0"
          }
        ]
      },
      "ledger": [
        {
          "sequence": 1,
          "at": "2026-08-31 21:33:29",
          "draft_path": "documents/requirements-draft-v1-9569137a152d-cad_61118b0b03ba_inv_cbe0d9057fa.json",
          "draft_revision": 1,
          "event": "requirements_draft_updated",
          "invocation_id": "cad_61118b0b03ba_inv_cbe0d9057fa9c392",
          "item_count": 7
        },
        {
          "sequence": 2,
          "at": "2026-08-31 21:33:34",
          "draft_revision": 1,
          "event": "requirements_review_requested",
          "invocation_id": "cad_61118b0b03ba_inv_06bbea193838a2fc"
        },
        {
          "sequence": 3,
          "at": "2026-08-31 21:33:57",
          "event": "requirements_review_revise",
          "invocation_id": "cad_61118b0b03ba_inv_e2c8d7369fe13f8e",
          "review_path": "documents/requirements-review-ad5c325ac148-cad_61118b0b03ba_inv_e2c8d7369fe.json"
        },
        {
          "sequence": 4,
          "at": "2026-08-31 21:34:09",
          "draft_path": "documents/requirements-draft-v2-61b42ee7c0c5-cad_61118b0b03ba_inv_d94f7195643.json",
          "draft_revision": 2,
          "event": "requirements_draft_patched",
          "invocation_id": "cad_61118b0b03ba_inv_d94f71956434ed71",
          "item_count": 7
        },
        {
          "sequence": 5,
          "at": "2026-08-31 21:34:12",
          "draft_revision": 2,
          "event": "requirements_review_requested",
          "invocation_id": "cad_61118b0b03ba_inv_c7caf81afa71f667"
        },
        {
          "sequence": 6,
          "at": "2026-08-31 21:34:19",
          "event": "requirements_evaluation_oracle_revise",
          "invocation_id": "cad_61118b0b03ba_inv_576f30faa568cb0c",
          "missing_claims": [
            {
              "claim_kind": "collinear_through_bore_chain",
              "expected": {
                "adjacent_distances_mm": [
                  60,
                  80
                ],
                "diameter_mm": 12,
                "tolerance_mm": 0.1
              }
            }
          ],
          "oracle_path": "documents/evaluation-contract-oracle-e9f00ebbf0e1.json",
          "review_path": "documents/requirements-review-83c51572391b-cad_61118b0b03ba_inv_576f30faa56.json"
        },
        {
          "sequence": 7,
          "at": "2026-08-31 21:34:36",
          "draft_path": "documents/requirements-draft-v3-1e78fc5e001e-cad_61118b0b03ba_inv_c4f29c79aef.json",
          "draft_revision": 3,
          "event": "requirements_draft_patched",
          "invocation_id": "cad_61118b0b03ba_inv_c4f29c79aef5c797",
          "item_count": 7
        },
        {
          "sequence": 8,
          "at": "2026-08-31 21:34:40",
          "draft_revision": 3,
          "event": "requirements_review_requested",
          "invocation_id": "cad_61118b0b03ba_inv_2443bcac857a1442"
        },
        {
          "sequence": 9,
          "at": "2026-08-31 21:35:04",
          "event": "requirements_review_revise",
          "invocation_id": "cad_61118b0b03ba_inv_ba791c6e359e7a0c",
          "review_path": "documents/requirements-review-95eef23b7115-cad_61118b0b03ba_inv_ba791c6e359.json"
        },
        {
          "sequence": 10,
          "at": "2026-08-31 21:35:04",
          "draft_revision": 3,
          "event": "requirements_review_limit_reached"
        }
      ],
      "invocations": [
        {
          "invocation_id": "cad_61118b0b03ba_inv_cbe0d9057fa9c392",
          "idempotency_key": "3877c33a9dbd2ad4976f8fe4ea308e8107f9bf3124b8a9e9c18392b72a076f26",
          "status": "finished",
          "result": {
            "result_type": "accepted",
            "payload": {
              "draft_revision": 1,
              "draft_ids": [
                "draft_001",
                "draft_002",
                "draft_003",
                "draft_004",
                "draft_005",
                "draft_006",
                "draft_007"
              ]
            }
          },
          "created_at": "2026-08-31 21:33:29",
          "updated_at": "2026-08-31 21:33:29"
        },
        {
          "invocation_id": "cad_61118b0b03ba_inv_06bbea193838a2fc",
          "idempotency_key": "a1e1a18a87923a110048a5fae5831964103010bcea0cf527d75643216682b042",
          "status": "finished",
          "result": {
            "result_type": "accepted",
            "payload": {
              "phase": "REVIEWING_REQUIREMENTS",
              "draft_revision": 1
            }
          },
          "created_at": "2026-08-31 21:33:34",
          "updated_at": "2026-08-31 21:33:34"
        },
        {
          "invocation_id": "cad_61118b0b03ba_inv_e2c8d7369fe13f8e",
          "idempotency_key": "345fc76130f8145f19339cc33947555e1a2e8b1438a6538d66262e29ca397085",
          "status": "finished",
          "result": {
            "result_type": "accepted",
            "payload": {
              "phase": "DRAFTING_REQUIREMENTS",
              "review": {
                "verdict": "revise",
                "coverage": [
                  {
                    "source_id": "src_001",
                    "requirement_ids": [
                      "req_001",
                      "req_002",
                      "req_003",
                      "req_004",
                      "req_005",
                      "req_006",
                      "req_007"
                    ]
                  }
                ],
                "item_verdicts": [
                  {
                    "draft_id": "draft_001",
                    "verdict": "pass",
                    "reason_code": "none",
                    "question": null
                  },
                  {
                    "draft_id": "draft_002",
                    "verdict": "pass",
                    "reason_code": "none",
                    "question": null
                  },
                  {
                    "draft_id": "draft_003",
                    "verdict": "pass",
                    "reason_code": "none",
                    "question": null
                  },
                  {
                    "draft_id": "draft_004",
                    "verdict": "pass",
                    "reason_code": "none",
                    "question": null
                  },
                  {
                    "draft_id": "draft_005",
                    "verdict": "pass",
                    "reason_code": "none",
                    "question": null
                  },
                  {
                    "draft_id": "draft_006",
                    "verdict": "revise",
                    "reason_code": "claim_unverifiable",
                    "question": null
                  },
                  {
                    "draft_id": "draft_007",
                    "verdict": "pass",
                    "reason_code": "none",
                    "question": null
                  }
                ],
                "issues": [
                  "The 32 mm outer lobe diameter and smooth outer contour are represented by scoped visual claims, but the deterministic verifier has a known capability gap for validating these outer-circle/blend requirements; draft_006 also includes an unavailable executable outer_cylindrical_surface claim for that gap."
                ]
              }
            }
          },
          "created_at": "2026-08-31 21:33:57",
          "updated_at": "2026-08-31 21:33:57"
        },
        {
          "invocation_id": "cad_61118b0b03ba_inv_d94f71956434ed71",
          "idempotency_key": "f981d2a32d680102e21e350fd1ffe82a4829e9c59b99538c15d2be72cd9629c1",
          "status": "finished",
          "result": {
            "result_type": "accepted",
            "payload": {
              "draft_revision": 2,
              "item_count": 7
            }
          },
          "created_at": "2026-08-31 21:34:09",
          "updated_at": "2026-08-31 21:34:09"
        },
        {
          "invocation_id": "cad_61118b0b03ba_inv_c7caf81afa71f667",
          "idempotency_key": "610c505fca1dd1a4afe5585e6dfad5e029d0e781041d167db0154a46121052eb",
          "status": "finished",
          "result": {
            "result_type": "accepted",
            "payload": {
              "phase": "REVIEWING_REQUIREMENTS",
              "draft_revision": 2
            }
          },
          "created_at": "2026-08-31 21:34:12",
          "updated_at": "2026-08-31 21:34:12"
        },
        {
          "invocation_id": "cad_61118b0b03ba_inv_576f30faa568cb0c",
          "idempotency_key": "b6bb4084c9d5c29a410d9d95a589f71cabb39a8cfdad871a2e086047eb1e5a27",
          "status": "finished",
          "result": {
            "result_type": "accepted",
            "payload": {
              "phase": "DRAFTING_REQUIREMENTS",
              "review": {
                "schema_version": "cad.requirements-evaluation-oracle.v1",
                "task_id": "cad_61118b0b03ba",
                "evaluation_only": true,
                "verdict": "revise",
                "draft_revision": 2,
                "reviewer_verdict": "pass",
                "reviewer_review_path": "documents/requirements-review-83c51572391b-cad_61118b0b03ba_inv_576f30faa56.json",
                "item_verdicts": [
                  {
                    "draft_id": "draft_001",
                    "verdict": "revise",
                    "reason_code": "evaluation_contract_oracle"
                  },
                  {
                    "draft_id": "draft_002",
                    "verdict": "revise",
                    "reason_code": "evaluation_contract_oracle"
                  },
                  {
                    "draft_id": "draft_003",
                    "verdict": "revise",
                    "reason_code": "evaluation_contract_oracle"
                  },
                  {
                    "draft_id": "draft_004",
                    "verdict": "revise",
                    "reason_code": "evaluation_contract_oracle"
                  },
                  {
                    "draft_id": "draft_005",
                    "verdict": "revise",
                    "reason_code": "evaluation_contract_oracle"
                  },
                  {
                    "draft_id": "draft_006",
                    "verdict": "revise",
                    "reason_code": "evaluation_contract_oracle"
                  },
                  {
                    "draft_id": "draft_007",
                    "verdict": "revise",
                    "reason_code": "evaluation_contract_oracle"
                  }
                ],
                "issues": [
                  "The external live-evaluation contract oracle found missing executable acceptance claims."
                ],
                "missing_claims": [
                  {
                    "claim_kind": "collinear_through_bore_chain",
                    "expected": {
                      "diameter_mm": 12,
                      "adjacent_distances_mm": [
                        60,
                        80
                      ],
                      "tolerance_mm": 0.1
                    }
                  }
                ]
              },
              "reviewer_review_path": "documents/requirements-review-83c51572391b-cad_61118b0b03ba_inv_576f30faa56.json",
              "evaluation_oracle": {
                "missing_claims": [
                  {
                    "claim_kind": "collinear_through_bore_chain",
                    "expected": {
                      "diameter_mm": 12,
                      "adjacent_distances_mm": [
                        60,
                        80
                      ],
                      "tolerance_mm": 0.1
                    }
                  }
                ]
              }
            }
          },
          "created_at": "2026-08-31 21:34:19",
          "updated_at": "2026-08-31 21:34:19"
        },
        {
          "invocation_id": "cad_61118b0b03ba_inv_c4f29c79aef5c797",
          "idempotency_key": "2d00902c522d478617eb26e505c20d2178546e0a45397340ba94c35d477544d5",
          "status": "finished",
          "result": {
            "result_type": "accepted",
            "payload": {
              "draft_revision": 3,
              "item_count": 7
            }
          },
          "created_at": "2026-08-31 21:34:36",
          "updated_at": "2026-08-31 21:34:36"
        },
        {
          "invocation_id": "cad_61118b0b03ba_inv_2443bcac857a1442",
          "idempotency_key": "ff489a45f8a239834a465e9e28efce6a105f831359dbd295be81110327e9cb4e",
          "status": "finished",
          "result": {
            "result_type": "accepted",
            "payload": {
              "phase": "REVIEWING_REQUIREMENTS",
              "draft_revision": 3
            }
          },
          "created_at": "2026-08-31 21:34:40",
          "updated_at": "2026-08-31 21:34:40"
        },
        {
          "invocation_id": "cad_61118b0b03ba_inv_ba791c6e359e7a0c",
          "idempotency_key": "3a9f1710d14c5146405b94c39ca44e8b3db4ab55676e2cbddcd5ae943d0db5d4",
          "status": "finished",
          "result": {
            "result_type": "accepted",
            "payload": {
              "phase": "DRAFTING_REQUIREMENTS",
              "review": {
                "verdict": "revise",
                "coverage": [
                  {
                    "source_id": "src_001",
                    "requirement_ids": [
                      "req_001",
                      "req_002",
                      "req_003",
                      "req_004",
                      "req_005",
                      "req_006",
                      "req_007"
                    ]
                  }
                ],
                "item_verdicts": [
                  {
                    "draft_id": "draft_001",
                    "verdict": "pass",
                    "reason_code": "none",
                    "question": null
                  },
                  {
                    "draft_id": "draft_002",
                    "verdict": "pass",
                    "reason_code": "none",
                    "question": null
                  },
                  {
                    "draft_id": "draft_003",
                    "verdict": "pass",
                    "reason_code": "none",
                    "question": null
                  },
                  {
                    "draft_id": "draft_004",
                    "verdict": "pass",
                    "reason_code": "none",
                    "question": null
                  },
                  {
                    "draft_id": "draft_005",
                    "verdict": "pass",
                    "reason_code": "none",
                    "question": null
                  },
                  {
                    "draft_id": "draft_006",
                    "verdict": "revise",
                    "reason_code": "claim_unverifiable",
                    "question": null
                  },
                  {
                    "draft_id": "draft_007",
                    "verdict": "revise",
                    "reason_code": "claim_unverifiable",
                    "question": null
                  }
                ],
                "issues": [
                  "Known validation capability gap: the 32 mm outer lobe diameter and smooth outer contour are represented by scoped visual claims only because deterministic executable validation for linkage outer circles/blended segments is unavailable in the current registry."
                ]
              }
            }
          },
          "created_at": "2026-08-31 21:35:04",
          "updated_at": "2026-08-31 21:35:04"
        }
      ],
      "event_audit": [
        {
          "name": "tool_call",
          "tool": "submit_requirements_draft_batch",
          "status": "success",
          "code": "",
          "raw_arguments_hash": "8fbb73db04f9d70dd7e37dc17b29a9769f032e019356f8854d89eb0e9e82323c",
          "field_errors": []
        },
        {
          "name": "tool_call",
          "tool": "finalize_requirements_draft",
          "status": "success",
          "code": "",
          "raw_arguments_hash": "44136fa355b3678a1146ad16f7e8649e94fb4fc21fe77e8310c060f61caaff8a",
          "field_errors": []
        },
        {
          "name": "requirements_review",
          "tool": "",
          "status": "error",
          "code": "AUTHOR_FORMAT_INVALID",
          "raw_arguments_hash": "",
          "field_errors": [
            {
              "path": "/",
              "message": "Value error, pass requires every draft item to pass and forbids unresolved issues"
            }
          ]
        },
        {
          "name": "requirements_review",
          "tool": "",
          "status": "success",
          "code": "",
          "raw_arguments_hash": "",
          "field_errors": []
        },
        {
          "name": "tool_call",
          "tool": "patch_requirements_draft",
          "status": "success",
          "code": "",
          "raw_arguments_hash": "6193c963abbf512fa5e35a8341c03519eaac38c4625873d564d2bc296267c724",
          "field_errors": []
        },
        {
          "name": "tool_call",
          "tool": "finalize_requirements_draft",
          "status": "success",
          "code": "",
          "raw_arguments_hash": "44136fa355b3678a1146ad16f7e8649e94fb4fc21fe77e8310c060f61caaff8a",
          "field_errors": []
        },
        {
          "name": "requirements_review",
          "tool": "",
          "status": "success",
          "code": "",
          "raw_arguments_hash": "",
          "field_errors": []
        },
        {
          "name": "tool_call",
          "tool": "patch_requirements_draft",
          "status": "success",
          "code": "",
          "raw_arguments_hash": "8d1b6e26d94c397559dc1df3462b2d3ae1c3bee2849bde8deee99e0617c14301",
          "field_errors": []
        },
        {
          "name": "tool_call",
          "tool": "finalize_requirements_draft",
          "status": "success",
          "code": "",
          "raw_arguments_hash": "44136fa355b3678a1146ad16f7e8649e94fb4fc21fe77e8310c060f61caaff8a",
          "field_errors": []
        },
        {
          "name": "requirements_review",
          "tool": "",
          "status": "error",
          "code": "AUTHOR_FORMAT_INVALID",
          "raw_arguments_hash": "",
          "field_errors": [
            {
              "path": "/",
              "message": "Value error, pass requires every draft item to pass and forbids unresolved issues"
            }
          ]
        },
        {
          "name": "requirements_review",
          "tool": "",
          "status": "success",
          "code": "",
          "raw_arguments_hash": "",
          "field_errors": []
        },
        {
          "name": "task_terminal",
          "tool": "",
          "status": "",
          "code": "WAITING_FOR_USER",
          "raw_arguments_hash": "",
          "field_errors": []
        }
      ]
    }
  ],
  "suite": "comprehensive",
  "require_live": true,
  "report_root": "/Users/lk/Projects/cdsl-cad/backend/live-evals/20260831T212855Z"
}