{ "status": "failed", "author": { "provider": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.4-mini" }, "reviewer": { "provider": "openai", "model": "gpt-5.5" }, "author_capability": { "schema_hash": "fb899a5de2f869b648df88a32d04a5eee92ae3d193ab23ee641892d6b59cd8e7", "tool_count": 9, "supported": true, "failures": [], "usage": { "prompt_tokens": 41789, "completion_tokens": 1472 }, "mode": "openai_compatible_tool_calling" }, "reviewer_capability": { "schema_hash": "fb899a5de2f869b648df88a32d04a5eee92ae3d193ab23ee641892d6b59cd8e7", "tool_count": 9, "supported": true, "failures": [], "usage": { "prompt_tokens": 41789, "completion_tokens": 536 }, "mode": "openai_compatible_tool_calling" }, "results": [ { "scenario": "rectangular_plate", "repetition": 1, "success": true, "started_at": "2026-08-31T09:55:55.322896+00:00", "finished_at": "2026-08-31T09:56:56.059317+00:00", "terminal": { "taskId": "cad_f18ebbd436c7", "lifecycle": "completed", "revisionId": "rev_001" }, "projection": { "schema_version": "3.0", "task_id": "cad_f18ebbd436c7", "phase": "COMPLETED", "lifecycle": "completed", "state_version": 9, "active_revision": "rev_001", "current_revision": "rev_001", "published_revision": "rev_001", "pending_action": null, "active_candidate_id": "", "repair_required": false, "last_error": "", "action_ledger_summary": [ { "sequence": 1, "at": "2026-08-31 09:56:04", "draft_revision": 1, "event": "requirements_draft_updated", "item_count": 1 }, { "sequence": 2, "at": "2026-08-31 09:56:08", "draft_revision": 1, "event": "requirements_review_requested" }, { "sequence": 3, "at": "2026-08-31 09:56:14", "contract_hash": "5a77d1672adaecd4a1551764149b95abce0fdc2ed5d434b460e93bc5085caee9", "event": "requirements_contract_frozen", "requirement_count": 1 }, { "sequence": 4, "at": "2026-08-31 09:56:26", "action_id": "act_004", "atomic_id": "extrude_add_blind", "contract_hash": "fa9ffc9fd2141453fa18a389813dde2e2ef3fb4c7ef5d05e61d51d614309e95f", "event": "proposed", "expected_change": "Create a single solid rectangular plate measuring 80 mm by 50 mm by 8 mm in the current model.", "intent": "Build the base plate body to satisfy the dimensional requirement.", "requirement_ids": [ "req_001" ], "working_head": "cad_f18ebbd436c7:root:v3" }, { "sequence": 5, "at": "2026-08-31 09:56:34", "action_id": "act_004", "candidate_id": "candidate_fd1dd253fd90e2f2", "event": "candidate_building", "fragment_hash": "01a2f45e7ae8ef9e48f5dd39c74d65f0e83c82cf0c234deada7edd1507496fae" }, { "sequence": 6, "at": "2026-08-31 09:56:35", "action_id": "act_004", "candidate_id": "candidate_fd1dd253fd90e2f2", "claim_results": [ { "claim_id": "claim_001", "claim_kind": "solid_count_equals", "deterministic": true, "evidence": { "solid_count": 1 }, "status": "pass" }, { "claim_id": "claim_002", "claim_kind": "single_connected_body", "deterministic": true, "evidence": { "solid_count": 1 }, "status": "pass" }, { "claim_id": "claim_003", "claim_kind": "bbox_dimension_mm", "deterministic": true, "evidence": { "actual_mm": 80.0, "axis": "x", "tolerance_mm": 0.0 }, "status": "pass" }, { "claim_id": "claim_004", "claim_kind": "bbox_dimension_mm", "deterministic": true, "evidence": { "actual_mm": 50.0, "axis": "y", "tolerance_mm": 0.0 }, "status": "pass" }, { "claim_id": "claim_005", "claim_kind": "bbox_dimension_mm", "deterministic": true, "evidence": { "actual_mm": 8.0, "axis": "z", "tolerance_mm": 0.0 }, "status": "pass" } ], "event": "candidate_built" }, { "sequence": 7, "at": "2026-08-31 09:56:44", "action_id": "act_004", "actual_atomic_id": "extrude_add_blind", "candidate_id": "candidate_fd1dd253fd90e2f2", "coverage": [ { "claim_id": "claim_001", "claim_kind": "solid_count_equals", "deterministic": true, "evidence": { "solid_count": 1 }, "status": "pass" }, { "claim_id": "claim_002", "claim_kind": "single_connected_body", "deterministic": true, "evidence": { "solid_count": 1 }, "status": "pass" }, { "claim_id": "claim_003", "claim_kind": "bbox_dimension_mm", "deterministic": true, "evidence": { "actual_mm": 80.0, "axis": "x", "tolerance_mm": 0.0 }, "status": "pass" }, { "claim_id": "claim_004", "claim_kind": "bbox_dimension_mm", "deterministic": true, "evidence": { "actual_mm": 50.0, "axis": "y", "tolerance_mm": 0.0 }, "status": "pass" }, { "claim_id": "claim_005", "claim_kind": "bbox_dimension_mm", "deterministic": true, "evidence": { "actual_mm": 8.0, "axis": "z", "tolerance_mm": 0.0 }, "status": "pass" } ], "event": "accepted", "fragment_hash": "01a2f45e7ae8ef9e48f5dd39c74d65f0e83c82cf0c234deada7edd1507496fae", "review_path": "revisions/rev_001/candidate-review.json", "revision_id": "rev_001", "selector_snapshot_id": "", "working_head_before": "cad_f18ebbd436c7:root:v3" }, { "sequence": 8, "at": "2026-08-31 09:56:47", "claim_results": [ { "claim_id": "claim_001", "claim_kind": "solid_count_equals", "deterministic": true, "evidence": { "solid_count": 1 }, "status": "pass" }, { "claim_id": "claim_002", "claim_kind": "single_connected_body", "deterministic": true, "evidence": { "solid_count": 1 }, "status": "pass" }, { "claim_id": "claim_003", "claim_kind": "bbox_dimension_mm", "deterministic": true, "evidence": { "actual_mm": 80.0, "axis": "x", "tolerance_mm": 0.0 }, "status": "pass" }, { "claim_id": "claim_004", "claim_kind": "bbox_dimension_mm", "deterministic": true, "evidence": { "actual_mm": 50.0, "axis": "y", "tolerance_mm": 0.0 }, "status": "pass" }, { "claim_id": "claim_005", "claim_kind": "bbox_dimension_mm", "deterministic": true, "evidence": { "actual_mm": 8.0, "axis": "z", "tolerance_mm": 0.0 }, "status": "pass" } ], "event": "final_validation_requested", "revision_id": "rev_001" }, { "sequence": 9, "at": "2026-08-31 09:56:56", "claim_results": [ { "claim_id": "claim_001", "claim_kind": "solid_count_equals", "deterministic": true, "evidence": { "solid_count": 1 }, "status": "pass" }, { "claim_id": "claim_002", "claim_kind": "single_connected_body", "deterministic": true, "evidence": { "solid_count": 1 }, "status": "pass" }, { "claim_id": "claim_003", "claim_kind": "bbox_dimension_mm", "deterministic": true, "evidence": { "actual_mm": 80.0, "axis": "x", "tolerance_mm": 0.0 }, "status": "pass" }, { "claim_id": "claim_004", "claim_kind": "bbox_dimension_mm", "deterministic": true, "evidence": { "actual_mm": 50.0, "axis": "y", "tolerance_mm": 0.0 }, "status": "pass" }, { "claim_id": "claim_005", "claim_kind": "bbox_dimension_mm", "deterministic": true, "evidence": { "actual_mm": 8.0, "axis": "z", "tolerance_mm": 0.0 }, "status": "pass" } ], "event": "completed", "final_review_path": "revisions/rev_001/final-review.json", "revision_id": "rev_001" } ], "revisions": [ { "revision_id": "rev_001", "status": "success", "visibility": "final", "cdsl_path": "revisions/rev_001/model.cdsl.json", "step_path": "revisions/rev_001/model.step", "glb_path": "revisions/rev_001/model.glb", "report_path": "revisions/rev_001/rebuild-report.json", "candidate_review_path": "revisions/rev_001/candidate-review.json" } ] }, "usage": { "calls": 8, "prompt_tokens": 66683, "completion_tokens": 2143, "context_chars": 43886, "records": [ { "completion_tokens": 448, "context_chars": 878, "model_id": "gpt-5.4-mini", "prompt_tokens": 5234, "provider_id": "openai", "raw_arguments_hash": "004b933bbdcee2ec8a612472e0f5c36813bb55a2624b0100429390ac61b8076e", "tool": "submit_requirements_draft_batch", "total_tokens": 5682 }, { "completion_tokens": 79, "context_chars": 1673, "model_id": "gpt-5.4-mini", "prompt_tokens": 5448, "provider_id": "openai", "raw_arguments_hash": "44136fa355b3678a1146ad16f7e8649e94fb4fc21fe77e8310c060f61caaff8a", "tool": "finalize_requirements_draft", "total_tokens": 5527 }, { "completion_tokens": 71, "context_chars": 1159, "model_id": "gpt-5.5", "prompt_tokens": 5011, "provider_id": "openai", "raw_arguments_hash": "00996cae282886750e3169d668db3145d5aad3fa73c825b1b9d5d423613bdb52", "role": "reviewer", "tool": "review_requirements", "total_tokens": 5082 }, { "completion_tokens": 569, "context_chars": 1281, "model_id": "gpt-5.4-mini", "prompt_tokens": 4960, "provider_id": "openai", "raw_arguments_hash": "4bff6094579f7f30f0f888d2044ed6ad56b24ffc5117b4e25e1af85714df8bb7", "tool": "propose_next_action", "total_tokens": 5529 }, { "completion_tokens": 402, "context_chars": 2239, "model_id": "gpt-5.4-mini", "prompt_tokens": 5634, "provider_id": "openai", "raw_arguments_hash": "75e87f0b7034b3d9982873a523c40ff81dc255a14b2dbf23a1bf63d06be85113", "tool": "submit_cdsl_fragment", "total_tokens": 6036 }, { "completion_tokens": 277, "context_chars": 21836, "model_id": "gpt-5.5", "prompt_tokens": 19246, "provider_id": "openai", "raw_arguments_hash": "dc76df5308ce57cdbdd3c28c7f43d323996736ba584d9b7f0b430b3f17f701ad", "role": "reviewer", "tool": "review_candidate", "total_tokens": 19523 }, { "completion_tokens": 65, "context_chars": 4046, "model_id": "gpt-5.4-mini", "prompt_tokens": 6074, "provider_id": "openai", "raw_arguments_hash": "44136fa355b3678a1146ad16f7e8649e94fb4fc21fe77e8310c060f61caaff8a", "tool": "complete_task", "total_tokens": 6139 }, { "completion_tokens": 232, "context_chars": 10774, "model_id": "gpt-5.5", "prompt_tokens": 15076, "provider_id": "openai", "raw_arguments_hash": "65cb6d82f5b65bb4c0e32cea6db1c093949c76b5cdc6b1871cf772934a7915eb", "role": "reviewer", "tool": "review_final", "total_tokens": 15308 } ] }, "checks": { "expected_terminal_phase": true, "token_budget": true, "call_budget": true, "author_turn_budget": true, "reviewer_turn_budget": true, "required_claims": true, "required_operations": true, "required_operation_alternative": true, "immutable_artifacts": true, "unique_revisions": true, "raw_argument_audit": true, "no_schema_or_decision_rejections": true }, "rejection_codes": [], "artifact_root": "/Users/lk/Projects/cdsl-cad/backend/live-evals/20260831T095431Z/artifacts/cad_f18ebbd436c7" }, { "scenario": "simple_flange", "repetition": 1, "success": false, "started_at": "2026-08-31T09:56:56.061618+00:00", "finished_at": "2026-08-31T10:00:03.260135+00:00", "terminal": { "taskId": "cad_e1261e227f5c", "lifecycle": "failed", "code": "FAILED_AUTHOR_FORMAT", "message": "Author repeatedly failed the same canonical schema or state contract." }, "projection": { "schema_version": "3.0", "task_id": "cad_e1261e227f5c", "phase": "FAILED", "lifecycle": "failed", "state_version": 9, "active_revision": "rev_001", "current_revision": "rev_001", "published_revision": "", "pending_action": null, "active_candidate_id": "", "repair_required": false, "last_error": "FAILED_AUTHOR_FORMAT", "action_ledger_summary": [ { "sequence": 10, "at": "2026-08-31 09:57:11", "draft_revision": 1, "event": "requirements_draft_updated", "item_count": 1 }, { "sequence": 11, "at": "2026-08-31 09:57:15", "draft_revision": 1, "event": "requirements_review_requested" }, { "sequence": 12, "at": "2026-08-31 09:57:23", "contract_hash": "7a31c9479ee38b16ce3aa77a1eece02a1a889b8b98cba8d11059977acb26118a", "event": "requirements_contract_frozen", "requirement_count": 1 }, { "sequence": 13, "at": "2026-08-31 09:57:34", "action_id": "act_004", "atomic_id": "extrude_add_blind", "contract_hash": "fa9ffc9fd2141453fa18a389813dde2e2ef3fb4c7ef5d05e61d51d614309e95f", "event": "proposed", "expected_change": "Create a 120 mm outer-diameter, 12 mm-thick cylindrical base solid in millimetres.", "intent": "Establish the flange body before adding the centered 40 mm through bore.", "requirement_ids": [ "req_001" ], "working_head": "cad_e1261e227f5c:root:v3" }, { "sequence": 14, "at": "2026-08-31 09:57:44", "action_id": "act_004", "candidate_id": "candidate_585ceff4e4616a5c", "event": "candidate_building", "fragment_hash": "95bd1e739aed6d4a791a162b2ce05d84d0a52f4d18dc87c11dc7d6e8d7761078" }, { "sequence": 15, "at": "2026-08-31 09:57:46", "action_id": "act_004", "candidate_id": "candidate_585ceff4e4616a5c", "claim_results": [ { "claim_id": "claim_001", "claim_kind": "solid_count_equals", "deterministic": true, "evidence": { "solid_count": 1 }, "status": "pass" }, { "claim_id": "claim_002", "claim_kind": "single_connected_body", "deterministic": true, "evidence": { "solid_count": 1 }, "status": "pass" }, { "claim_id": "claim_003", "claim_kind": "bbox_dimension_mm", "deterministic": true, "evidence": { "actual_mm": 120.0, "axis": "x", "tolerance_mm": 0.1 }, "status": "pass" }, { "claim_id": "claim_004", "claim_kind": "bbox_dimension_mm", "deterministic": true, "evidence": { "actual_mm": 120.0, "axis": "y", "tolerance_mm": 0.1 }, "status": "pass" }, { "claim_id": "claim_005", "claim_kind": "bbox_dimension_mm", "deterministic": true, "evidence": { "actual_mm": 12.0, "axis": "z", "tolerance_mm": 0.1 }, "status": "pass" }, { "claim_id": "claim_006", "claim_kind": "through_cylindrical_bore", "deterministic": true, "evidence": { "reason": "the target bore has not been introduced at this checkpoint" }, "status": "pending" } ], "event": "candidate_built" }, { "sequence": 16, "at": "2026-08-31 09:57:57", "action_id": "act_004", "actual_atomic_id": "extrude_add_blind", "candidate_id": "candidate_585ceff4e4616a5c", "coverage": [ { "claim_id": "claim_001", "claim_kind": "solid_count_equals", "deterministic": true, "evidence": { "solid_count": 1 }, "status": "pass" }, { "claim_id": "claim_002", "claim_kind": "single_connected_body", "deterministic": true, "evidence": { "solid_count": 1 }, "status": "pass" }, { "claim_id": "claim_003", "claim_kind": "bbox_dimension_mm", "deterministic": true, "evidence": { "actual_mm": 120.0, "axis": "x", "tolerance_mm": 0.1 }, "status": "pass" }, { "claim_id": "claim_004", "claim_kind": "bbox_dimension_mm", "deterministic": true, "evidence": { "actual_mm": 120.0, "axis": "y", "tolerance_mm": 0.1 }, "status": "pass" }, { "claim_id": "claim_005", "claim_kind": "bbox_dimension_mm", "deterministic": true, "evidence": { "actual_mm": 12.0, "axis": "z", "tolerance_mm": 0.1 }, "status": "pass" }, { "claim_id": "claim_006", "claim_kind": "through_cylindrical_bore", "deterministic": true, "evidence": { "reason": "the target bore has not been introduced at this checkpoint" }, "status": "pending" } ], "event": "accepted", "fragment_hash": "95bd1e739aed6d4a791a162b2ce05d84d0a52f4d18dc87c11dc7d6e8d7761078", "review_path": "revisions/rev_001/candidate-review.json", "revision_id": "rev_001", "selector_snapshot_id": "", "working_head_before": "cad_e1261e227f5c:root:v3" }, { "sequence": 17, "at": "2026-08-31 09:58:05", "action_id": "act_008", "atomic_id": "hole_blind", "contract_hash": "f62e12603feeca6d7e83acdab651fcb023e08a46c39fd1509e9dcb81d4f0c721", "event": "proposed", "expected_change": "Add a centered 40 mm diameter blind hole through the 12 mm flange thickness, removing material from one face to create the through bore.", "intent": "Introduce the centered bore required by the flange specification while keeping the body a single connected solid.", "requirement_ids": [ "req_001" ], "working_head": "cad_e1261e227f5c:rev_001:v7" }, { "sequence": 18, "at": "2026-08-31 10:00:03", "event": "failed_author_format", "field_errors": [], "tool": "submit_cdsl_fragment" } ], "revisions": [ { "revision_id": "rev_001", "status": "success", "visibility": "checkpoint", "cdsl_path": "revisions/rev_001/model.cdsl.json", "step_path": "revisions/rev_001/model.step", "glb_path": "revisions/rev_001/model.glb", "report_path": "revisions/rev_001/rebuild-report.json", "candidate_review_path": "revisions/rev_001/candidate-review.json" } ] }, "usage": { "calls": 10, "prompt_tokens": 72681, "completion_tokens": 10235, "context_chars": 50920, "records": [ { "completion_tokens": 548, "context_chars": 934, "model_id": "gpt-5.4-mini", "prompt_tokens": 5242, "provider_id": "openai", "raw_arguments_hash": "0624ba33ca1696c191aaa3d60abfdeb4ef805d6ec4f9a949d70001dcebf3d978", "tool": "submit_requirements_draft_batch", "total_tokens": 5790 }, { "completion_tokens": 140, "context_chars": 1931, "model_id": "gpt-5.4-mini", "prompt_tokens": 5510, "provider_id": "openai", "raw_arguments_hash": "44136fa355b3678a1146ad16f7e8649e94fb4fc21fe77e8310c060f61caaff8a", "tool": "finalize_requirements_draft", "total_tokens": 5650 }, { "completion_tokens": 71, "context_chars": 1377, "model_id": "gpt-5.5", "prompt_tokens": 5069, "provider_id": "openai", "raw_arguments_hash": "00996cae282886750e3169d668db3145d5aad3fa73c825b1b9d5d423613bdb52", "role": "reviewer", "tool": "review_requirements", "total_tokens": 5140 }, { "completion_tokens": 566, "context_chars": 1347, "model_id": "gpt-5.4-mini", "prompt_tokens": 4980, "provider_id": "openai", "raw_arguments_hash": "7e4557b99bdcb3a86e6f5179d210a593366a7a34ba331216cc1a6025bf6f438b", "tool": "propose_next_action", "total_tokens": 5546 }, { "completion_tokens": 529, "context_chars": 2296, "model_id": "gpt-5.4-mini", "prompt_tokens": 5661, "provider_id": "openai", "raw_arguments_hash": "23829cf9a299ebb4730966c58369597723709d4bbc0ebc4984898749ab2c97f1", "tool": "submit_cdsl_fragment", "total_tokens": 6190 }, { "completion_tokens": 269, "context_chars": 22280, "model_id": "gpt-5.5", "prompt_tokens": 19510, "provider_id": "openai", "raw_arguments_hash": "bc2d6c0dd17595091d5c45a76988fb8911228fc637435ec306df256aed0de72c", "role": "reviewer", "tool": "review_candidate", "total_tokens": 19779 }, { "completion_tokens": 375, "context_chars": 4552, "model_id": "gpt-5.4-mini", "prompt_tokens": 6198, "provider_id": "openai", "raw_arguments_hash": "013a8a345baf8848619ae741c8375c03fab94771b062ce641d5c46f2ddfb0e7e", "tool": "propose_next_action", "total_tokens": 6573 }, { "completion_tokens": 3431, "context_chars": 5167, "model_id": "gpt-5.4-mini", "prompt_tokens": 6787, "provider_id": "openai", "raw_arguments_hash": "65863e9517d4417def1a18f5cf89c0f77ffe21f82e4262b63340c81aec568819", "tool": "submit_cdsl_fragment", "total_tokens": 10218 }, { "completion_tokens": 3690, "context_chars": 5518, "model_id": "gpt-5.4-mini", "prompt_tokens": 6862, "provider_id": "openai", "raw_arguments_hash": "d56f3f8cfec1a7e5619c9a001110cbac4d260b6a3ce226257f5968a66b48619c", "tool": "submit_cdsl_fragment", "total_tokens": 10552 }, { "completion_tokens": 616, "context_chars": 5518, "model_id": "gpt-5.4-mini", "prompt_tokens": 6862, "provider_id": "openai", "raw_arguments_hash": "d287cddf623758d4f47e68663ba7cd1aef15a298c23221f5dbcf22959676e0df", "tool": "submit_cdsl_fragment", "total_tokens": 7478 } ] }, "checks": { "expected_terminal_phase": false, "token_budget": true, "call_budget": true, "author_turn_budget": true, "reviewer_turn_budget": true, "required_claims": true, "required_operations": true, "required_operation_alternative": false, "immutable_artifacts": true, "unique_revisions": true, "raw_argument_audit": true, "no_schema_or_decision_rejections": true }, "rejection_codes": [], "artifact_root": "/Users/lk/Projects/cdsl-cad/backend/live-evals/20260831T095431Z/artifacts/cad_e1261e227f5c" } ], "suite": "smoke", "require_live": true, "report_root": "/Users/lk/Projects/cdsl-cad/backend/live-evals/20260831T095431Z" }